Saggio Hills: Has Healdsburg reached an impasse with developers?
Published: Tuesday, July 15, 2008 at 7:17 a.m.
Last Modified: Tuesday, July 15, 2008 at 7:19 a.m.
The developers of a proposed luxury hotel and residential project in Healdsburg are being asked to pay more for the cost of building a fire station, a move that threatens to bring developers and councilmembers to a stand-off.
The Saggio Hills luxury resort project continues through the government approval process that included a public hearing Monday. But with the city asking for more concessions from developers, it remains unclear who will blink first.
“We could get to the point where we’re at an impasse. Then it might be like an Old West stand-off, without guns,” Vice Mayor Jim Wood said late Monday, following the latest City Council hearing on the project.
Healdsburg officials are eager to capture the revenue Saggio Hills is projected to generate: at least $63 million by 2024, mostly in the form of bed taxes from the 130-room, five-star resort.
But the city wants developers to help finance a 37-acre community park and pay the full cost of a fire station, in exchange for getting their project, which includes 70, multi-million dollar homes, approved on 258 acres on the northern edge of town.
A year ago the concessions included donating 14 acres for an affordable housing site, 37 acres for a community park, about an acre of land and up to $1 million toward building a fire substation.
But Wood and Councilman Mike McGuire both said Monday they want to see the developers pay the whole cost of the fire station, now estimated at about $2 million.
Developers Robert Green and Tony Korman said they’re not ready to make that move.
“We’ve been negotiating for two years. Every time we’re asked to do more. At some point, we have to say ‘We can’t do more,’ ” Green said in a brief interview.
He said Saggio Hills will bring “unbelievable benefits” to the city and will more than double the $1.7 million in bed taxes the city collected from all its hotels and lodging facilities the past fiscal year.
Several speakers at Monday’s public hearing said it makes sense for the developers to foot the full cost of the fire station since it would service Saggio Hills.
Fire Chief Randy Collins said the new station is needed in order for firefighters to respond to Saggio Hills structures in less than five minutes.
But developer Korman said the fire station will benefit not only Saggio, but the “whole north end of Healdsburg.”
Some speakers Monday suggested the developers put up all the money to finance the regional park.
The developers have agreed to donate the land and pay $3 million toward the cost of building the $8 million park. But Healdsburg resident Richard Burg said instead of the city issuing $5 million in bonds to make up for the difference, the developers should put up all the money and let the city pay back its portion over time.
Monday was the seventh public hearing the council has devoted to Saggio Hills since April.
Two more City Council public hearings on the project remain; one is set for 7 p.m. Wednesday and another Aug.6.
Only three council members are weighing the application, since two others have disqualified themselves due to potential conflicts.
All rights reserved. This copyrighted material may not be re-published without permission. Links are encouraged.
Comments are currently unavailable on this article