Tiger Woods joins long list of rehabbed brands in America
Published: Saturday, April 10, 2010 at 3:00 a.m.
Last Modified: Friday, April 9, 2010 at 6:07 p.m.
Tiger Woods' penchant for cocktail waitresses and porn actresses ended up costing an astonishing amount of money: two economists at the U
Brand Tiger is thus likely to join a long list of brands that have come back refreshed after a spell in rehab. These include not just the predictable roster of celebrity brands such as Martha Stewart and Kobe Bryant, but also a surprising number of solid corporate citizens such as Johnson & Johnson and Coca-Cola.
Brand-threatening scandals are becoming a regular feature of the corporate landscape, thanks to a toxic mixture of globalization, which scatters corporate activities hither and yon, and the Internet, which allows bad news to spread like wildfire.
Oxford Metrica, a consultancy, estimates that executives have an 82 percent chance of facing a corporate disaster within any five-year period, up from 20 percent two decades ago. Indeed, just the day after Woods made his return to golf, the American government fined Toyota over $16 million for its tardiness in addressing safety concerns.
The key to a successful relaunch lies in making a cool-headed assessment of how much the scandal damages your company.
Does it involve life and limb, rather than less consequential matters? Has it spread beyond particular products or particular divisions to afflict the entire corporate brand? If the answer to both questions is yes, then companies are well advised to go into collective overdrive; if it is no, then they can experiment with more nuanced responses, such as lopping off a tainted product or sacrificing a rogue division.
Marsh & McLennan and JetBlue provide good examples of companies that took a no-holds-barred approach to brand rehabilitation.
The firm was not content with issuing groveling apologies and paying $850 million in compensation. It also appointed a new boss, Michael Cherkasky, who was the head of its financial investigation division, Kroll. Cherkasky proceeded to de-emphasize the insurance business and boost other divisions, such as Mercer Consulting and Kroll.
In 2007 bad weather presented JetBlue with a nightmare of its own. Thousands of passengers were left stranded and one planeload of unfortunates spent eight hours sitting on the tarmac, with precious little food or drink to sustain them.
The company's founder and boss, David Neeleman, immediately recognized that this made a mockery of his promise to “bring humanity back to air travel.” He threw himself into dealing with the problem, issuing public apologies, telling his employees to contact passengers personally by phone and e-mail, producing a retroactive passengers' “Bill of Rights” and ponying up around $25 million in compensation.
The JetBlue case underlines two of the most important rules of successful crisis management. First, the boss needs to take charge. This means sidelining corporate cluck-cluckers such as lawyers (who worry that any admission of guilt will lead to lawsuits) or financial officers (who obsess about the bottom line).
It also means putting the survival of the company above personal considerations (Neeleman stepped down three months after the crisis). Many of the most damaging crises, by contrast, have resulted from foot-dragging at the top — as appears to be the case with Toyota today.
The second rule is that crisis-racked firms should redouble their focus on their customers. One former aide to George Bush junior, David Frum, tells the story of another, Karen Hughes, who sees a small plane towing a banner reading, “Jill, please come back. I am nothing without you. Jack.” Her response is, “Wrong message.
Companies have a habit of acting like Jack when their brands are in trouble — talking endlessly about how they are fixing this or reorganizing that. But most successful decontaminators look at the world's from Jill's point of view.
Johnson & Johnson's handling of the Tylenol crisis (when an unidentified attacker poisoned some bottles of the painkiller) is the gold standard of crisis management because the company simply recalled all Tylenol without hesitation or demur.
Similarly, Edward Breen, the boss of Tyco, rescued the conglomerate's reputation after his predecessor, Dennis Kozlowski, was imprisoned, by launching a public-relations campaign that focused on what the company's products do to improve people's lives.
Crises can even give brands a long-term boost, provided the rehabilitation is properly handled. Coca-Cola emerged stronger from its disastrous recipe change in 1985.
Tiger Woods, too, could well emerge with added luster from his own debacle. There is nothing Americans like more than a redemption story — particularly when the man being redeemed is supremely good at his job.
From the Economist magazine.
All rights reserved. This copyrighted material may not be re-published without permission. Links are encouraged.