Register | Forums | Log in

COURSEY: Don't sell our parks short

Published: Friday, February 3, 2012 at 7:20 a.m.
Last Modified: Friday, February 3, 2012 at 7:20 a.m.

If a private concessionaire can help keep open state parks such as Sugarloaf Ridge or Hendy Woods or Austin Creek, I'm all for making the deal.

But let's not just give away this valuable business.

Thursday's Page 1 story by Derek Moore says the California Public Works Board gave the go-ahead on Wednesday for the state Parks Department to seek bids from private and non-profit concessionaires interested in running campgrounds, restaurants, day-use facilities and other profit centers within dozens of state parks that otherwise are slated for closure on July 1. The plan would require the concessionaire to return a minimum 3 percent of revenues to the state.

The state should hold out for more.

By “bundling” park concessions – Sugarloaf, for example, would be included in a contract with five parks in the Central Valley – the Parks Department estimates that each concession contract would represent about $500,000 in annual revenues. A 3-percent return would provide the state about $15,000 a year from each contract.

I'm willing to bet it will cost the state more than that to administer the contract.

Turning over public concessions to private companies shouldn't be done lightly, and it shouldn't be done without a real value and adequate return to the public. Keeping the parks open is good, but we shouldn't subsidize private concessions.

Look to Yosemite National Park for an example. Sugarloaf is no Yosemite, of course – no park can compare. But when the National Park Service went to look for a new concessionaire in 1993 after the Curry Co. had run the park's campgrounds and hotels and other concessions for nearly 100 years, the feds didn't settle for the less-than-one-percent return that Curry had been paying all those years. The new concessionaire, Delaware North Cos., pays more than 20 percent of its annual gross receipts back to the park.

A similar return on a $500,000 state park concession contract would generate $100,000 a year.

Maybe 20 percent is an unreasonable amount to ask a concessionaire to pay for running a few campsites and parking areas. But, from the public's side of the equation, 3 percent is too low.

Let's not sell our parks short.

Chris Coursey's blog offers a community commentary and forum, from issues of the day to the ingredients of life in Sonoma County.

All rights reserved. This copyrighted material may not be re-published without permission. Links are encouraged.

▲ Return to Top