After 16 years of discord, delays, and litigation that belied its modest length, the 1.3-mile East Slope Sonoma Mountain Ridge Trail received its final approval from Sonoma County supervisors on Tuesday.
“It is amazing to me how long it has taken and how many people have been involved, and I am honored to be the last of the supervisors working on this issue in a really focused and determined way,” said Supervisor Susan Gorin, who represents the area, noting that the issue had outlasted the terms of two predecessors.
Supervisor Shirlee Zane said the matter was so drawn out that Tuesday's vote represented “a relief rather than a celebration.”
The trail will extend the existing ridge trail in Jack London State Park, winding through oak groves and grassland across several pieces of private property to a scenic overlook offering expansive views down the Sonoma Valley.
The idea had seemed relatively uncontroversial when it was first proposed in 1997. The county's Agricultural Preservation and Open Space District had secured permission from property owners and construction began on portions of the trail.
When one key property owner sold his land in 2001, however, lawyers discovered that the paperwork to give the county an easement had never been completed, allowing the new buyer to reject the trail, even though it was already under construction.
The county sued both the former property owner, Tom McCrae, and the buyers, the Maria Hansen Trust. It was not until 2009 that the case was fully settled, with the trust donating a slice of land along the ridge line to the Open Space District.
Meanwhile, the Open Space District and other organizations interested in the trail had to finalize agreements with other landowners and calm the worries of nearby homeowners, who were concerned that a trail might mean trespassing, littering, and other crime in their formerly isolated mountainside neighborhood.