57°
Cloudy
WED
 89°
 54°
THU
 86°
 56°
FRI
 85°
 53°
SAT
 88°
 57°
SUN
 89°
 56°

Disaster shows Korea is growing too fast

  • Rescue helicopters fly over a sinking South Korean passenger ferry that was carrying more than 450 passengers, mostly high school students, Wednesday, April 16, 2014, off South Korea's southern coast. Hundreds of people are missing despite a frantic, hours-long rescue by dozens of ships and helicopters. At least four people were confirmed dead and 55 injured. (AP Photo/Yonhap) KOREA OUT

TOKYO

The concept of "balle balle!" or "quick, quick!" is at the very core of Koreans' view of themselves. After rising from the ashes of war in the 1950s, bouncing back from financial collapse in the late 1990s, and growing into a technology-and-entertainment powerhouse over the past decade, South Korea has turned its ability get the job done in a bewilderingly short time into a national hallmark.

But amid grief, recriminations and breathless news coverage, the investigation into the tragic sinking of the passenger ferry Sewol on April 16 has exposed deep cracks in this narrative. Details of the crew's actions leading up to the accident — when an inexperienced, 26-year-old third mate was guiding the huge ferry — and their confusion during the botched evacuation, paint a picture of potentially criminal incompetence. Families outraged by how long it's taken to recover the bodies of their loved ones have trained their anger on the government, whose skills at crisis management have looked disturbingly weak.

While I've criticized Malaysia for its dismal handling of the the search for missing Malaysian Airlines Flight 370, the government there is burdened by a one-party system that has bred incompetence and hubris. What explains this calamity in high-tech, proudly democratic Korea?

What we have here is an object lesson of the limits of using rapid gross domestic product as the dominant metric for a nation's success. The Sewol tragedy is a wakeup call for Korea to address the blind spots in its political and business culture.

One accident is no reason to indict an entire government, never mind 50 million people. Any attempt to do so is as hyperbolic as it is unfair. The developed and developing worlds alike have reason to be awed by Korea's economic triumphs — beating the dreaded middle-income trap, creating a stable of companies that have Apple and Toyota looking over their shoulders, blanketing the world with its K-pop music, edgy movies and television dramas.

But man-made disasters reveal much about how far a nation really has come, and when it's time to plot a new course. Korea's problems trace in part from the collision between its quick-quick culture and a government that remains obsessed with bureaucracy, hierarchy and turf.

Why, for example, did it take nearly one hour for the government's Central Disaster and Safety Countermeasures Headquarters to begin rescue efforts for the 476 people, 325 of them high school students, on the ferry? In February, President Park Geun-hye decided to strengthen the Security Ministry's role in disaster management — a move that de-emphasized the more experienced National Emergency Management Agency. All Koreans, not just distraught family members, have a right to question whether such moves have hurt or helped the government's ability to withstand crises.

Korean business culture also deserves a thorough re-examination. Are ferry operators putting lives at risk to boost profits in a hyper-competitive environment? Should ships plying domestic waters like the Sewol be subject to the more stringent safety standards applied to those that sail internationally?


comments powered by Disqus
© The Press Democrat |  Terms of Service |  Privacy Policy |  Jobs With Us |  RSS |  Advertising |  Sonoma Media Investments |  Place an Ad
Switch to our Mobile View