SAN FRANCISCO — Of course, you praise the 49ers for the amazing, unexpected, thrilling season that ended Sunday on the soft, wet, muddy turf of old Candlestick Park.
You praise them for being excellent and for bringing the thrill back to Northern California football and for competing bravely, even heroically. And you acknowledge they made one of the historic turnarounds in NFL history, going from a low-level, unimportant team in the 2011 season to the NFC championship game this season. Amazing. Praiseworthy. The 49ers are a team this area of the country should feel proud of.
But alongside the praise, it is essential to write about the game that ended things, the 20-17 loss to the Giants, almost certainly a better team, although the 49ers defeated them in the regular season. And it is obvious the 49ers offense failed — that sounds unkind, but there is no gentle way to put it.
NFC Championship Game
In the first half, the 49ers — Alex Smith — attempted seven passes and completed two. What do we make of those numbers, of that elementary-school math?
We say the numbers are trivial. We say a good team easily can throw seven passes on a single drive and complete more than two in the natural course of play. The Niners did none of that.
And please don't blame the weather. The weather is such a tired excuse. The Packers often play in snow and high school teams play in rain all over America, and when it comes down to it, the Giants played on the same field as the Niners and they threw more passes for more yards — not even close.
There is a rule when you play wet games on a wet field — the 49ers must know this because they play at the 'Stick. You throw in the first half when the field is relatively stable and you run in the second half when it's a mess. The Niners did just the opposite and that was a mistake. The Niners also converted one third down all game. That was dreadful verging on disheartening and this total offensive floperoo leads to the main point, a Jim Harbaugh point.
Harbaugh is all about guts and glory. He talks like a tough guy — and he may actually be a tough guy — and he lectures players and reporters on being relentless, on taking chances, on being mighty men, on being wicked, on battling, etc.
A team that aspires to the Super Bowl must crave a win in the NFC championship game. Harbaugh would say — he really would — a potential Super Bowl team takes what it wants. It doesn't wait around or hope or dither. It just takes. It blows the other guys away.
In the first half, the 49ers took nothing. They should have been absolutely ferocious but they were meek. Their game plan was stodgy and conservative and dull. Seven passes, for heaven's sake. Harbaugh or Greg Roman or whoever calls the plays over there conducted himself more like a cost accountant than a win-at-all-costs football coach. This was the championship game. Where was the passion? Where were the Niners?