Dale Curtis Gaines didn't kill or rape anyone. He wasn't in a gang and he didn't get caught selling drugs to kids.
The Santa Rosa man was convicted in 1998 of possession of stolen property after he tried to sell computer equipment taken in a burglary from a local charity.
Because of his long rap sheet, he received the maximum prison sentence -- 27 years to life -- under California's tough "three strikes" sentencing law targeting career criminals.
Now, Gaines has joined a half-dozen other inmates from Sonoma County who are seeking their freedom following the passage in November of Proposition 36, which eased the state's mandatory sentencing law. The voter-approved initiative amended the law to require third strikes be violent or serious.
Gaines, 55, was sent to prison at least two previous times for burglaries dating back to 1986, but he's never been convicted of a violent act. A legal team from Stanford Law School is preparing to ask the courts to reduce Gaines' sentence. They are expected to file a request for resentencing that lays out a plan for his return to society.
"We believe that he can come out and be a successful member of the community," said Michael Romano, director of Stanford's Three Strikes Project. "He's certainly not a threat to public safety."
Since last year, the team has been seeking his release on grounds that his trial attorney failed to tell the judge that Gaines was "mentally retarded" and suffered mental illness, according to court records. They cited a letter from his prosecutor, who condemned the punishment as too harsh.
Jill Ravitch, Sonoma County's district attorney, is opposing Gaines' initial bid, arguing in court papers that he had an extensive criminal history, was mentally fit and met the spirit of three-strikes sentencing.
She has not said if she will try to block his release under Prop. 36. She didn't return calls last week seeking comment.
In a previous interview, Ravitch said she would consider an inmate's criminal history and prison behavior in taking her position. She expressed concern about supervision once inmates were freed.
But already, Judge Shelly Averill has signaled an interest in Gaines' case. She ordered the district attorney to show good cause why his petition shouldn't be granted and asked whether Prop. 36 makes it moot.
A hearing is set for March 1.
Gaines is one of a handful of North Coast residents serving life prison sentences under the old three-strikes law, enacted in 1995 to target repeat criminals.
Since its adoption, critics said it unfairly punished people convicted of minor third felonies and contributed to prison crowding. They point to lower maximum sentences for the most serious crimes such as rape, which is eight years, and second-degree murder, which is 15 years to life.
In November, the state's voters overwhelmingly approved a key change. Now, in order to be eligible for a 25-to-life sentence, the third strike must be violent or serious.
Convicts serving life sentences for less serious offenses can apply for resentencing and in some cases be released.
Getting out won't be automatic, lawyers say. State prison officials have not given prosecutors access to key records requested for the first Sonoma County inmate to seek freedom. Jeff Michael Porter, 49, is serving a 27-to-life sentence on his 1999 car theft conviction.
Read all of the PD's fire coverage here