Fisherman's Sonoma Valley pond at center of airport dispute

  • Josh Frazier, owner of Leland Fly Fishing Outfitters, walks with his daughters Elle, 4, left, and Kohl, 6, at the edge of the two-acre pond on his Leland Ranch property, in Sonoma, Calif., on September 27, 2013. (Alvin Jornada / The Press Democrat)

At Leland Fly Fishing Ranch south of Sonoma, owner Josh Frazier sat on a deck overlooking a pond that he built and stocked with trout, but one that he is barred from casting a line in.

Concerns that the pond could attract birds and pose a threat to pilots taking off and landing at Sonoma Valley Airport, which is adjacent to the Arnold Drive ranch, are at the center of Frazier's long-running land-use dispute with county officials and the airport owners.

Frazier, 39, on this morning dismissed the concerns as "bull----." But with the future of his fly-fishing business on the line, he promised to abide by the ban, which the county imposed in 2012.

Leland Fly Fishing Ranch


"They can trust me to follow the rules," he said.

Even by the rough-and-tumble standards of county land-use disputes, Frazier's fight has achieved rare frenzy, spawning anger, mistrust, legal sparring and allegations that public safety is being unnecessarily compromised.

"It's been heated. It's a hot local topic," said Dick Fogg, a county planning commissioner.

On Oct. 24, the county Board of Zoning Adjustments is scheduled to take up Frazier's application for approval of a retail shop and other buildings on the 13-acre Leland Ranch property, as well as the controversial 2-acre pond, which is alternately described as a "water feature" or "landscape feature" in staff reports.

The terminology infuriates Chris Prevost and Sheryl Carlucci, who bought the airport in 2008 and want the Leland pond gone. The couple say Frazier should not be rewarded for building on his property and then, after the fact, seeking permits for the work.

"It's illegal. Why should it be there?" Carlucci said at the airport recently.

Frazier purchased Fly Fishing Outfitters in 1999 and added "Leland" to the name to honor his grandfather. He and his wife, Laurel, who live in San Francisco, bought the Arnold Drive property in 2004 for $650,000, envisioning it as the ideal place for a fly-fishing school, retail hub and launching pad for adventures on North Coast rivers and streams.

© The Press Democrat |  Terms of Service |  Privacy Policy |  Jobs With Us |  RSS |  Advertising |  Sonoma Media Investments |  Place an Ad
Switch to our Mobile View