Lowell Cohn: A's blow their chance to bury Tigers

  • Oakland Athletics right fielder Josh Reddick stretches but is unable to catch a solo home run by Detroit Tigers' Victor Martinez, as fans reach for the ball during the seventh inning of Game 4 of baseball's American League division series in Detroit, Tuesday, Oct. 8, 2013. (AP Photo/Duane Burleson)

DETROIT - Of course, the A's blew the golden opportunity.

Of course, they had Game 4 won, leading the Tigers 3-0 after 4? innings, starting pitcher Dan Straily throwing a no-hitter through four, cruising, gliding, styling. The game actually was boring, the A's doing the same old thing, just dominating the helpless Tigers.

And then, well, you know what happened. The Tigers came to life — what did you expect? — and won 8-6, and this series moves back to Oakland for the fifth and final game. Win or lose. Move on or go home. Do or die.

Oakland A's vs. Detroit Tigers ALDS Game 4


There is something fitting, even appropriate, about how this is playing out. The A's are in a great/awful position. They must prove they're the better team. To do that, they need to get past Justin Verlander a second time. There is honor in getting past Verlander to win this series. And there is glory. Don't forget that.

The dramatic moment in Game 4 was top of the seventh. Detroit manager Jim Leyland sent in pitcher Max Scherzer, the game tied 3-3. In his pregame media conference Leyland had said he might do this. Leyland never tries to deceive, always tells the truth. So many managers and coaches should emulate him.

As Scherzer warmed up on the mound at 7 p.m., the sky turned gray and the stadium lights got bright. Something special was happening.

Scherzer is the best pitcher in the American League. He's the guy who won Game 1. His presence as a reliever, so unusual, meant Leyland was doing everything to win — actually, to stop losing. Leyland was yanking Scherzer from his Game 5 start because Game 5 didn't matter, didn't exist, might never exist. Leyland's world, the Tigers' world, Detroit's world was this game right here right now.

And all those worlds needed Scherzer to lock down the A's. Leyland could not trust this to his bullpen. Scherzer was a would-be savior.

Scherzer gave up a run in the seventh, putting the A's up by one. That doesn't concern us here. Scherzer came out again to pitch the eighth, Leyland sticking with him for dear life, the Tigers now up by a run. Scherzer loaded the bases with nobody out. This was the A's chance, their glowing opportunity to bury Scherzer who had no business being there. Bury him. Bury the Tigers. Sit in a Detroit hotel and leisurely watch the Red Sox-Rays game before traveling home or to Boston. Everything was there for the taking.

Josh Reddick came up. Determined. Feisty. Dangerous. The count went full, Scherzer laboring, missing the plate. And then he threw a crummy pitch, pitiful, slow, in the dirt, a changeup. Reddick swung. Missed. See ya.

© The Press Democrat |  Terms of Service |  Privacy Policy |  Jobs With Us |  RSS |  Advertising |  Sonoma Media Investments |  Place an Ad
Switch to our Mobile View