Let's say you're playing Jeopardy and the information you're given is this:
With a .667 batting average, two homers and seven RBIs in his underdog team's four-game sweep, he likely would have won the World Series Most Valuable Player Award except that the award's existence didn't begin until the following year.
Let's say your answer, given in Jeopardy-speak, is: Who is Dusty Rhodes?
Take a bow.
It's World Series time again, and the thoughts of at least one aging New York born-and-raised Giants fan turn to Mr. James Lamar Rhodes. The fear is that younger baseball fans, and especially younger Giants fans, might not know of Rhodes' feats in the 1954 Series. The legend of Dusty Rhodes is a heck of a story, worth telling, worth remembering. And worth putting in context.
In 1954, Rhodes, 27, was a scrub, a pinch hitter and part-time outfielder. He had 186 plate appearances, the equivalent of playing about one-third of the season. His numbers, though — 15 homers, 50 runs batted in, a .341 batting average and a .410 on-base percentage — if calculated over a full year were those of a superstar.
Then came the '54 Series, the underdog New York Giants against a Cleveland Indians team that had won a then-American League record 111 games.
In Game 1, with more than 52,000 fans packed into the old Polo Grounds in Harlem, the score was 2-2 in the bottom of the 10th inning. With one out, future Hall of Famer Bob Lemon walked Willie Mays, who then stole second base. Cleveland manager Al Lopez ordered an intentional walk to Hank Thompson, and that brought the aging future Hall of Famer Monte Irvin to the plate. Irvin had gone 0 for 3 against Lemon, striking out once. Giants manager Leo Durocher countered by sending up Rhodes to pinch hit.
You need to know that the Polo Grounds was a ballpark with the most magnificently odd features, the likes of which we'll certainly never see again. Bullpens were on the field, in fair territory, tucked away in deep right-center and left-center. The locker rooms and Giants executive offices were housed in an edifice (which included a scoreboard, clock and huge cigarette billboard) that was also on the field, in dead center, in between the bleachers.
Distance between home plate and the right-field foul pole was only 279 feet. Subtract about 20 feet when factoring in a second-deck overhang. A pop fly hit just so, and it's a home run.
Rhodes, pinch hitting in the bottom of the 10th inning of Game 1 of the 1954 World Series, hit a pop fly just so.
Here's further context.
Earlier in Game 1, in the top of the eighth and the score 2-2, Cleveland had two runners on and no out, with lefty-hitting Vic Wertz at bat. The Giants brought in left-hander Don Liddle to face him. Wertz hit a majestic shot that soared about 440 feet, give or take. You see, straightaway center at the Polo Grounds was 483 feet from home plate. Mays, sprinting with his back to the plate, made one of the iconic catches in baseball history, in front of the bleachers just to the right of straightaway center.
Liddle, removed after pitching only to Wertz, had waited for the Giants' next pitcher, Marv Grissom, to arrive at the mound and reportedly deadpanned, "Well, I got my man."