Plastic bag bans will be up to cities after countywide effort fizzles

The ban on single-use plastic bags long sought by Sonoma County environmentalists is unlikely to materialize as a single countywide law but rather as a patchwork of similar, if not identical, local ordinances.

The board of the Sonoma County Waste Management Agency, bowing to pressure from cities including Santa Rosa, recently approved two changes to its charter that set the stage for cities to opt out of a future bag ban.

The decision, if ratified in coming months by the nine cities and the county that are members of the agency, breaks the impasse that arose over whether cities could pass and enforce their own bans.

"If this is the way it needs to happen in order for us to enact something countywide, then that's what we have to do," said Cotati City Councilwoman Susan Harvey, co-chairwoman of the board. "You have to compromise sometimes."

Harvey said the board shifted its position once it became "obvious that what we had was not going anywhere."

A countywide ban has been discussed for more than five years as a way to reduce litter and reliance on oil-based products. In addition to staff time expenditures, the Waste Management Agency spent about $38,000 on an environmental study for the proposal.

Staff at the agency, which was created in 1992 to increase and coordinate recycling efforts, argued that a countywide ban would create the kind of consistent rules that consumers and retailers want, making the ban more effective.

Some city attorneys, however, questioned whether the agency's joint powers authority gave it the power to pass such a ban. They also argued that individual cities should be allowed to opt out if they preferred to pass their own laws.

Since the countywide ban needed to be unanimous to be implemented, opposition from even one city would have killed the effort.

Third District Supervisor Shirlee Zane said she was pleased a compromise was reached that allowed the ordinance to move forward.

© The Press Democrat |  Terms of Service |  Privacy Policy |  Jobs With Us |  RSS |  Advertising |  Sonoma Media Investments |  Place an Ad
Switch to our Mobile View