PD Editorial: The cascading expenses of incarceration

  • Inmates are moved at the Sonoma County's Main Adult Detention Facility in Santa Rosa, Friday May 24 2013. Instead of those incarcerated moving in to the state prison system, inmates are being held longer in county jail to lessen the burden on overcrowding at state facilities. (Kent Porter / Press Democrat) 2013

California counties are getting a dollars-and-cents lesson the state learned the hard way: Putting people behind bars isn't cheap — and there aren't any easy alternatives.

No politician wants to be handcuffed to the next Willie Horton, and voters usually support stiff sentences. Yet it's safe to assume that citizens demanding more for their tax dollars aren't thinking about state prisons or county jails.

In California, however, federal judges are.

The state remains under order to reduce crowding in prisons that, until recently, were filled to twice their design capacity. To comply, the state has transferred thousands of non-violent inmates to county jails.

Now, counties are starting to feel the pressure.

In Sonoma County, as Staff Writer Julie Johnson reported, about 20 percent of jail inmates would have gone to prison prior to the 2011 realignment. One local inmate is serving 15 years in a jail where the maximum term used to be one year.

"We are hiring staff, but that isn't keeping up with influx of inmates," Sheriff Steve Freitas said. "We have extreme overtime rates and worker-related injuries and burnout related to that."

Looking ahead, he expects a hefty cost increase in health care costs when the county negotiates a new contract for medical services in the jail. The present contract expires next year. Health care, Freitas said, "is truly the 800-pound gorilla."

It's easy to say inmates aren't entitled to medical care, but the courts have ruled otherwise. A panel of federal juges ruled in 2009 that health care in state prisons was so poor that it constituted cruel and unusual punishment, resulting in the order to reduce the inmate population. The state's challenges failed all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Since 2010, the prison population has declined from 163,000 to about 120,000. Voters helped by approving a measure to adjust three-strikes sentences, one of the few recent initiatives to reduce the prison population.

© The Press Democrat |  Terms of Service |  Privacy Policy |  Jobs With Us |  RSS |  Advertising |  Sonoma Media Investments |  Place an Ad
Switch to our Mobile View