Kathleen Miller is desperately afraid that her disabled son could not survive outside the Sonoma Developmental Center.
She previously tried moving Dan Smith, who is 46 and has autism and bipolar disorder, into board-and-care homes. Both times he was kicked out.
"It was horrible," said Miller, 67, who lives just north of Santa Rosa.
Her son's future and that of 1,510 of California's most vulnerable residents is on the line with a new task force that will recommend whether the state's four developmental centers are still viable or should be scrapped.
California's Health and Human Services Agency is leading the effort, which again confronts the long-standing dilemma of where best to care for people whose disabilities are so profound they require constant and expensive monitoring.
Developmental centers are saddled with aging infrastructure, declining populations and, in the case of the facility in Sonoma Valley, loss of federal funding related to problems that include patient abuse.
But community-care options, as Miller can attest, aren't a panacea.
"This has been the only home they've known," Sonoma County Supervisor Susan Gorin, whose district includes the developmental center, said of the nearly 500 people who reside at the facility, the largest of its kind in the state. "It's just not safe for them to be in these group homes or community care centers."
The demise of developmental centers has long been predicted in California. Advocates of keeping the institutions open are particularly worried in this instance by the timing of the task force and its stated mission, which includes setting a "timeline for future closures."
The panel was created following media reports detailing graphic examples of abuse at the state's developmental centers and the failure of law enforcement to properly investigate the crimes. The Sonoma center has given up federal funding for 112 seriously disabled patients amid investigations into problems at the troubled facility.
In an effort to correct the problems and restore that funding, the center has entered into a federally approved performance improvement plan
Karen Faria, the center's new executive director, declined comment through a spokesman. In a May 22 letter to staff obtained by The Press Democrat, she wrote that the task force does not change the center's mission.
"All the staff of Sonoma have lived and worked through some hard times lately and I am confident that, despite the unpredictable future we face, we all will continue our commitment to the people we serve," she wrote.
A spokesman for the state's Health and Human Services Agency also declined to say whether the task force is a clear indication the state is moving to shut developmental centers.
To Miller, it seems obvious.
"I think the task force is another notch in that direction," she said.
Nevertheless, Miller, who is president of the center's Parent Hospital Association, accepted a personal invitation from Diana Dooley, secretary of the state Health Agency, to be a member of the panel.
"Am I going to say, 'No,' in having a voice in helping to shape the future? Please. No way. I have to do that," she said.
The task force will begin meeting no later than June 15 and is supposed to wrap up by Nov. 15.
State Sen. Noreen Evans, D-Santa Rosa, said she understands why those who have loved ones at developmental centers might look askance at the task force.
Housing in Santa Rosa
Housing units constructed in Santa Rosa in the last 5 years: 1,258
Housing units possible on 3 county-owned sites in Santa Rosa: nearly 1,200
Chanate Road, former county hospital complex
Size: 82 acres
Total units proposed: 867 (162 affordable)
Sales price: $6 million — $11.5 million
2150 W. College Ave., former Water Agency headquarters
Size: 7.5 acres
Total units proposed: 144 (29 affordable)*
*New development proposals being solicited
Roseland Village shopping center, Dollar Tree site
Size: 7 acres
Total units proposed: 175 (75 affordable)