Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae say county-backed solar loans are liens against their houses

  • Catherine Williams and her husband are unable to refinance their home after putting $56,000 into a solar energy program this past spring.

Catherine Williams and Stephen Parsons used a Sonoma County energy retrofit program this spring to finance a solar energy system for their home outside Sebastopol.

A few weeks later a lender told them they couldn't refinance their home.

The couple is caught in a dispute that pits federal housing officials against a burgeoning national energy retrofit movement, generally known as Property Assessed Clean Energy. In tension are two national goals: on the one hand, reducing lending risks from home foreclosures and, on the other, creating green jobs and reducing energy consumption.

Williams said she has been told "there's really no chance of us being able to sell our house or refinance our house" due to their participation in the Sonoma County Energy Independence Program. Given today's historically low rates, she maintains, the inability to refinance could cost the couple "tens of thousands of dollars" over the next 30 years.

Sonoma's program, which allows special government financing for solar power and other energy-saving improvements, was the first countywide program in the nation.

To date the county has loaned $30 million for 900 improvement projects. Property owners repay the funds over 20 years, plus interest, with their annual property tax bills.

Similar efforts are gearing up around the state and the nation, some benefitting from federal stimulus aid.

By year's end, roughly three out of four California homeowners may be able to seek financing for such improvements. And more than 20 states have authorized such programs, as California did two years ago.

But in early May the federally backed agencies Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac put a cloud over such programs by telling lenders they won't allow the debt from such government financing to receive preference over the mortgages they purchase.

Since then, lenders have told a handful of county program participants that their energy financing must be paid off completely before a new mortgage will be provided for a sale or refinancing.

© The Press Democrat |  Terms of Service |  Privacy Policy |  Jobs With Us |  RSS |  Advertising |  Sonoma Media Investments |  Place an Ad
Switch to our Mobile View