Rarity: Sonoma County judge closes portion of gang murder trial to public

A Sonoma County judge Tuesday closed her courtroom to the public during testimony from a Santa Rosa gang member charged with murdering a Vallejo musician in an apparent case of mistaken identity.

Judge Dana Simonds removed all but lawyers and the jury to allow Christopher "Spider" Mancinas, 31, to testify about a "discreet issue" related to his role as an FBI informant.

Simonds reopened the courtroom after about 30 minutes. She said from the bench that the public and media had been excluded to ensure Mancinas received a fair trial and so he could speak freely.

All records and transcripts related to the testimony were to be sealed.

"There was no other way to do this to allow Mr. Mancinas to have a fair trial," Simonds said after reopening the court.

Prosecutors objected to the rare move, arguing Mancinas' work for the FBI already had been revealed in other testimony and that the public has a right to attend trials.

"We certainly favor an open courtroom with free access," Deputy District Attorney Bob Waner said after Tuesday's closure.

The closure followed more than three hours of testimony from Mancinas, an ex-convict who apparently straddled the disparate worlds of gangs and cops.

He is charged along with three other Santa Rosa gang members with killing Dewey Tucker, 24, as Tucker drove to a music rehearsal on Interstate 80 in Contra Costa County.

Police believe the four men followed the wrong car out of a Vallejo apartment complex on Jan. 12, 2010, drove alongside it on the freeway and fired, killing Tucker, whom they thought was a rival.

© The Press Democrat |  Terms of Service |  Privacy Policy |  Jobs With Us |  RSS |  Advertising |  Sonoma Media Investments |  Place an Ad
Switch to our Mobile View