Letter of the Day: Informed reviews

  • 5/20/2007: B6: ABOVE: Santa Rosa restaurant owner Guy Fieri, who has made the big time on The Food Network, serves as the parade's Grand Marshal.

    PC: News/--Santa Rosa's own Guy Fieri a, local chef who has made the big time on The Food Network, is the Grand Marshal of the 113th Annual Luther Burbank Rose Parade and Festival, Saturday May 19, 2007 in Santa Rosa. (Kent Porter / The Press Democrat) 2007

    Rose Festival

<i>Informed reviews</i>

EDITOR: New York Times critic Pete Wells' review of Guy Fieri's Times Square restaurant smacks of a vendetta ("The ultimate question for Fieri: Why?" Nov. 15). Fieri suggested that an "agenda" was responsible, and I submit that Fieri's assessment is more credible than the review.

I was a restaurant owner/operator in Sonoma County (the Blue Heron in Duncans Mills) during which time we were reviewed twice by Press Democrat critic Jeff Cox. The first review, awarded 4 ? stars (out of five), was better than we actually were, in my opinion. The second review (three stars), was, in my opinion, less than we deserved for various reasons. In each case we learned something because of intelligent, informed and specific reporting. The fact that I disagreed or agreed made no difference because the subjective report was honest.

Wells' review was unintelligent, almost written to be more clever than informative. Reviewing should be serious business, not a vindictive and vicious creative writing exercise.

Is it possible that there was not one positive observation to be made? Very unlikely, and to this point, the entire credibility of the review is on trial. Nothing was edible? More like nothing Wells had to say was believable.



© The Press Democrat |  Terms of Service |  Privacy Policy |  Jobs With Us |  RSS |  Advertising |  Sonoma Media Investments |  Place an Ad
Switch to our Mobile View