COHN: Raiders need roster overhaul

  • Darren McFadden turns the corner against the Broncos during Oakland's loss to Denver 26-13, Thursday Dec. 6, 2012 in Oakland. (Kent Porter / Press Democrat) 2012


The Raiders played the Denver Broncos Thursday night — prime time, no less. The Raiders lost 26-13. They have suffered worse losses this lost season, but now they have dropped six games in a row.

The game hardly mattered, anyway. The Raiders' season is over, and if you're intent on reading a story about the game, please read my friend Phil Barber, who writes entertaining and informative game stories.

Oakland Raiders vs. Denver Broncos


The Raiders have serious things at stake, more serious than the Broncos' game. Owner Mark Davis and general manager Reggie McKenzie have decisions to make — decisions now, decisions after this terrible season ends.

If the Raiders continue to get blown out for the balance of this season, despite everybody getting the Mark Davis message about showing improvement, McKenzie has to wonder if the players already have tuned out Dennis Allen. He must wonder if there is significant enough disconnect to make a coaching change after only one year.

I am not saying this is the case. I am saying McKenzie needs to consider it, needs to discover the truth and replace Allen, if that is the best course. If McKenzie dumps Allen after one season, Davis must seriously evaluate McKenzie's judgment. McKenzie is the GM who hired Allen even though he never had been a head coach.

McKenzie has other serious choices to make.

Is Carson Palmer their guy at quarterback for the long term? This is not clear. It certainly is not clear Palmer has earned long-term security. He makes great deep throws, exactly what Al Davis would have coveted. But he is erratic and careless and throws mind-numbing interceptions — he threw a beauty of that genre at the Broncos' end zone Thursday night. If the Raiders don't want Palmer, do they replace him with Matt Leinart or Terrelle Pryor?

The Raiders must decide if Darren McFadden is their guy at running back. McFadden has so much talent, he makes coaches drool. But he's always hurt and he is over-anxious in the Raiders' new run scheme and has trouble finding holes. The Raiders must ask if he is worth it.

McKenzie and Allen need to go through the entire roster and give a thumbs up or down to everyone. You assume the kickers get a thumbs up. That's a start. You don't assume that with Darrius-Heyward Bey or Richard Seymour or Tommy Kelly or Denarius Moore or Michael Huff. I could name just about everyone.

© The Press Democrat |  Terms of Service |  Privacy Policy |  Jobs With Us |  RSS |  Advertising |  Sonoma Media Investments |  Place an Ad
Switch to our Mobile View