COHN: Bonds doesn't get my Hall of Fame vote

  • PC: Barry Bonds of the Giants, March 5, 2001.

    3/30/2001: 1-C: Oakland's Jason Giambi and San Francisco's Barry Bonds, top left.

I am looking at three names on baseball's Hall of Fame ballot, recently mailed to me. The three names are Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens and Sammy Sosa. Those three names fill me with varying degrees of disgust. I will not vote for any of them.

I dismiss all three on ethical grounds. I believe they used performance enhancing drugs to bloat their statistics and prolong their careers.

Sosa is the easiest to reject. Before he took performance enhancing drugs, he was a good ballplayer but he was not destined for the Hall of Fame. Then suddenly — I would say magically — he was hitting home runs all over the place. He never had hit more than 40 home runs, and in 1998 he blasted 66.

Come on.

Sosa is the perfect example of baseball player as chemical creation. In a 2009 article, the New York Times listed Sosa as a player included on a list of drug cheaters.

Clemens is more troubling than Sosa — troubling to me as a voter trying to do the right thing, trying to be fair. I did not cover Clemens, so I have no first-hand knowledge of him as I do of Bonds, the emperor of all cheaters, in my opinion.

Clemens was mentioned 82 times in the Mitchell Report. Excuse me, but that's a lot of times. His career was beginning to dwindle, as all careers do, when — Presto! — he won 17 games in 2003 at age 40 and 18 games in 2004 at age 41.

Come on. Bodies don't work that way. Sports don't work that way. Life, unaltered by a secret potion, doesn't work that way.

I also know Andy Pettitte, a Clemens teammate and friend, fingered him as a PED user.

I make this one concession to Clemens. Because I didn't cover him, I keep my options open. He will be on the ballot another 14 times. If I learn more or learn different things, I may change my mind. There is nothing wrong in waiting to make an informed choice. I guess this could go for all three guys, although I doubt I will change my mind on the other two.

© The Press Democrat |  Terms of Service |  Privacy Policy |  Jobs With Us |  RSS |  Advertising |  Sonoma Media Investments |  Place an Ad
Switch to our Mobile View