Partly sunny

KRISTOF: Looking for lessons in Newtown's tragedy

After my column a few days ago urging tighter gun control<WC> ("Do we have the courage to stop this?" Monday)<WC1>, I faced incoming salvos from firearm enthusiasts. Let me respond to some of their arguments:<WC>

; Don't politicize the tragedy in Connecticut. This is a time for mourning, not for demonizing gun-owners.

Oh, come on! The president and Congress are supposed to address national problems — and every two months, we lose more Americans to gun violence than we did in the 9/11 attacks, according to data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

A study by the Children's Defense Fund found that we lose some 2,800 children and teenagers to guns annually.

That's more than the number of U.S. troops who have died in any year in Iraq and Afghanistan combined. More than twice as many preschoolers die annually from gun violence in America as law enforcement officers are killed in the line of duty.

So this is a time for mourning, yes, but it's time for President Barack Obama to display leadership as well as grief.

; What happened in Newtown, Conn., was heartbreaking, but gun laws are feel-good measures that don't make a difference. Norway has very restrictive gun laws, but it had its own massacre of 77 people.

It's true that the 1994 assault weapons ban was not very effective, even before it expired (partly because it had trouble defining assault weapons, and partly because handguns kill more people than assault rifles). But if that law's ban on the sale of high-capacity magazines had still been in effect, Adam Lanza, the gunman in Newtown, might have had to reload three times as often.

As for Norway, its laws did not prevent the massacre there last year. But, in a typical year, Norway has 10 or fewer gun murders. The U.S. has more than that in eight hours.

; If people want to kill, you can't stop them. Even a fork can be deadly. On the same day as the Connecticut tragedy, a man attacked 23 schoolchildren in China with a knife.

© The Press Democrat |  Terms of Service |  Privacy Policy |  Jobs With Us |  RSS |  Advertising |  Sonoma Media Investments |  Place an Ad
Switch to our Mobile View