Do police bear responsibility for a drunken person who is struck by a car during a traffic stop?
That's a question legal experts pondered Friday in the case of Dewayne Higgins, 53, of Santa Rosa, who was hit on Highway 101 Christmas night while being arrested in a suspected assault.
Civil attorneys agreed officers must use reasonable care to protect people in their custody from harm caused by others or themselves.
But factors such as the person's sobriety, attempts to escape or emerging threats could shift any liability away from officers.
Ultimately, a jury would have to decide whether the accident was a predictable outcome before awarding monetary damages.
"That's the whole question - was it foreseeable?" said Santa Rosa attorney Patrick Emery.
Investigators said Higgins and his 53-year-old girlfriend were passengers in her adult son's car sometime before 9:30 p.m.
The couple began to fight and Higgins punched the son, who pulled over in Windsor near the southbound Shiloh Road off ramp, Sonoma County Sheriff's Lt. Steve Brown said.
A passing CHP officer saw the car and stopped to check it out.
The officer saw Higgins drag the woman out and throw her to the ground, Brown said.