SAN FRANCISCO — The Battle of the Backups, as it turned out, was no battle at all. While the Chicago Bears' Jason Campbell folded under a barrage of sacks and hard hits, the 49ers' Colin Kaepernick established himself as a potential star.
The Niners delivered a 32-7 victory at Candlestick Park on Monday night, dismissing one of their primary playoff competitors as easily as Kaepernick eluded pass rushers.
Making his first NFL start, the second-year quarterback completed 16 of 23 passes for 243 yards, a pair of touchdowns and a passer rating of 133.1, doing most of the damage in the first half when this game was somewhat in question.
"We all know the talent that he has, and what he's capable of," wide receiver Kyle Williams said. "But him coming out there and just balling like that, making every throw, it's tough to say you expected him to come in and make every single throw like he did. It seemed as if he couldn't miss."
Kaepernick has enjoyed some nice moments as a spot fill-in for Alex Smith this season, but most of his appearances have had the whiff of novelty, with Kaepernick running as frequently as he threw. With Smith sidelined due to a concussion he suffered against the Rams last week, Kaepernick ignored the gimmickry and played like a classic QB. He threw from the pocket when he was able, passed on the run when he had to and distributed the ball to seven receivers.
The Bears more or less dared the 49ers to throw, stacking the box with eight or nine men to start the game. So Kaepernick threw, frequently after run-fakes, and it looked easy from the start.
As a point of reference, Joe Montana completed 5 of 12 passes for 36 yards in his first NFL start, for a passer rating of 49.3. Steve Young hit 16 of 27 for 167 yards (a rating of 77.2) in his debut with the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. Jeff Garcia was best of the three in his NFL premier, with 21 completions in 33 attempts for 243 yards and a pair of touchdowns; his rating was 106.0.
Kaepernick outdid all of those successful 49ers quarterbacks, leaving fans to ponder the long-term future of their offense — and the short-term as well, with Kaepernick potentially challenging Smith as the starter.
"I think right now we're in a situation where we have two great quarterbacks," left tackle Joe Staley said. "We won tonight with Kaepernick and we've won a lot of games with Alex. And Alex has played great football for us."
Indeed, Smith completed 25 of 27 passes in his previous two outings, before suffering a head injury on a fourth-and-1 sneak against the Rams.