55°
Cloudy
THU
 73°
 54°
FRI
 76°
 54°
SAT
 69°
 47°
SUN
 72°
 43°
MON
 73°
 47°

HERDT: Surprising views of crime victims

  • This artwork by Nancy Ohanian relates to prison reform, overcrowding and the prison population getting smaller for the first time in decades.

When former Lt. Gov. Abel Maldonado last month unofficially kicked off his campaign for governor by announcing the launch of a tough-on-crime ballot initiative, he had by his side Nina Salarno-Ashford, a member of the executive board for the group Crime Victims United. That group was founded by the mother of a murder victim, in close association with the state prison guards' union.

It has become an important voice in debates about crime-and-punishment issues in California because of the powerful empathy everyone feels for the suffering of those who have lost a loved one to violence. Its position, on issues from the three-strikes law to sentencing reform, has been consistent support for any policy that locks criminals in prison for as long as possible.

But is that how crime victims uniformly feel? Apparently not, judging from the results of a unique poll released last week that was commissioned by an advocacy group called Californians for Safety and Justice.

The polling firm David Binder Research randomly called 2,600 Californians to find 500 who said they had been victims of crime in the last five years. They, too, are deserving of empathy.

Two out of three said they had been the victims of multiple crimes, and the same percentage said they experienced significant stress and anxiety that affected their work and social relationships.

But their views on criminal justice, Binder says, are "at odds with preconceived notions." When asked whether California should "focus more on sending people to jail and prison or more on providing supervised probation and rehabilitation programs," they chose rehabilitation by a ratio of more than 2-to-1.

A majority of these crime victims said they believe California "sends too many people to prison" and that time spent in prison often results in criminals learning how to become better criminals.

Based on his polling, Binder came to this conclusion: "Victims want to focus on rehabilitation." The findings of the poll are noteworthy as policymakers evaluate the effects of the 2011 public safety realignment program that shifted about 30,000 low-level offenders from state prisons to county jails.

The shift was motivated in large part by the imperative to meet a U.S. Supreme Court order that California dramatically decrease its prison population. But it was also driven by the desire to spend money on corrections more efficiently and by the hope that locally based probation services would be more likely than the state parole system to provide effective rehabilitation.

Public safety realignment is the focus of Maldonado's ire. He calls the program "early release" and asserts that its architect, Gov. Jerry Brown, "has deceived the public into believing that they are safer under his public safety experiment."


© The Press Democrat |  Terms of Service |  Privacy Policy |  Jobs With Us |  RSS |  Advertising |  Sonoma Media Investments |  Place an Ad
Switch to our Mobile View