Access to disabled holds up debut of $4 million Santa Rosa fire station
Santa Rosa’s use of its $4 million Fountaingrove fire station has been delayed by questions about whether the new building is sufficiently accessible to people with disabilities.
The 5,300-square-foot Newgate Court station was supposed to be ready for occupancy in April, but last-minute inspections by city staff trained in the requirements of the Americans with Disabilities Act highlighted numerous potential violations.
The discovery has perplexed many at City Hall, especially given that the city has spent about $6 million over the past five years improving the accessibility of existing buildings, parks and sidewalks under the watchful eye of the U.S. Department of Justice.
It’s still unclear whether there are actually significant ADA or building code violations in the station. The Fire Department has hired an outside ADA consultant to review the facility and help determine what, if any, shortcomings exist, what changes need to be made, and how much they’ll cost.
“The building is ADA-accessible,” said Santa Rosa Fire Chief Tony Gossner. “What we’re struggling with is does it need to be fully accessible, and if so, what does that mean?”
The nine firefighters who will work and live in Station 5 are able-bodied by definition and obviously don’t require toilets, showers and countertops in the station to be wheelchair accessible. But as a public facility built with public money, questions have come up about how much of the building needs to be open to the public and therefore ADA-accessible.
The building was clearly designed with a degree of accessibility in mind. There is a disabled parking spot and pathway directly in front of the building. The lobby has a counter with a section lowered for people in wheelchairs to access.
Whether other parts of the building - such as the kitchen, dining room, lounge and bathrooms - need to be ADA accessible is an open question.
After a city facilities staff person raised questions in April, city building inspector Don Folsom performed an assessment and found 43 different potential compliance issues. Some, like the location of a grab bar or toilet paper holder in the bathroom, are minor and inexpensive to fix.
Others could be major expenses, such as removing the entire kitchen island because there is not enough room for someone in a wheelchair to maneuver around it, or taking out shower stalls because they’re not wide enough.
“That would be very disappointing,” Gossner said.
The department views most of the areas in the station as work areas for firefighters only. This includes the kitchen, dining room, lounge and living quarters, as well as the fire engine bays, Gossner said.
If any members of the public are in the facility, such as for a tour, firefighters would be with them at all times and able to accommodate their special needs if necessary, he said.
Some of the proposed requirements have struck Gossner as downright silly. For example, there are knobs on the walls throughout the station that control the volume of the radio system that alerts firefighters to calls being dispatched. Even if a member of the public were in the station, they have no reason to touch those controls and should not be doing so, Gossner said.
Nevertheless, these controls were identified as requiring a “pinch and twist” motion that may not be allowed for ADA-?accessible areas, Gossner said. A sliding switch was recommended instead, he said.
“It’s a little bit like, ‘Huh?’?” he said, scratching his head in confusion.
Some of the issues that have been identified are frustrating because of how close they are to meeting the standards, he said. A bookshelf in the lounge is 35 inches high, but may need to be 34. The shower entrance that is 58¾ inches wide may need to be 60 inches wide to comply.
City Manager Sean McGlynn said it is too soon to say how big the problem is, but he plans to get to the bottom of it. He said he expects the forthcoming consultant’s report will be instructive.
“Now we have to get into a deeper dive to see what is really an issue,” McGlynn said.
He said he’s more concerned about the city’s internal processes, and has asked Public Works Director Jason Nutt to come back in 60 days with a report about how the city got to this place.
“I have some questions about whether we’re in best practices mode,” he said.
The issue first became public during a City Council meeting when Councilwoman Julie Combs indicated she had heard of problems with an unfinished city building.
The fire station originally was designed around 2010 by architect Mitch Conner of Santa Rosa-based Archilogix and was built beginning in 2014 by GCCI Inc., also of Santa Rosa.
UPDATED: Please read and follow our commenting policy: