Amber Barretto, middle, shops with her children Lawrence, 10 and Christopher, 8, at Safeway in Windsor, Thursday Aug. 8, 2013. (Kent Porter / Press Democrat) File 2013

Grocery lifeline

Amber Barretto makes spaghetti for her two boys two or three nights a week. It's cheap, filling and has refrigerator shelf life.

"It's always good the second day," said Barretto, 30, a Larkfield single mother who is one of nearly 35,000 food stamp recipients in Sonoma County.

Barretto, who said she was laid off from a $14-an-hour job at a local tourist attraction in December, gets $330 a month in food credits from the safety net program known as CalFresh in California.

The money runs out 10 days to two weeks into the month, she said, an experience that officials say is "nearly universal" for food stamp recipients who get the equivalent of $1.40 per meal.

The Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program, known as SNAP and launched nationwide in 1974, faces an uncertain future as House Republicans, after failing to pass a $20 billion cut in June, two weeks ago proposed a $40 billion cut. Both proposed cuts would be spread over 10 years.

Kim Seamans, director of the Sonoma County Human Services Department's Economic Assistance Division, said the proposed reduction is unprecedented in her 29-year career at the agency.

The latest proposal is aimed primarily at unemployed and underemployed people who work 20 or fewer hours a week, age 18 to 50, who are not raising children, limiting them to three months of SNAP benefits out of every three years.

The standard would apply to as many as 4 million food stamp recipients nationwide, including an estimated 3,266 in Sonoma County.

"I think it's to society's advantage to assist them," Seamans said. "It creates a healthier society and a more productive society."

Critics object to the cost of SNAP, which has swelled to $78 billion today, more than doubling from $33 billion in 2007, when the recession officially began. The program currently serves 47.7 million low-income people, or one in seven Americans.

There are 34,749 food stamp recipients in Sonoma County. That's nearly as many as the population of Rohnert Park and 2? times as many as the 13,596 recipients in 2007.

During that time, the county's unemployment rate climbed from 4.3 percent in 2007 to a peak of 10.5 percent in 2010, and since has dropped to 6.7 percent in June.

"We see an increase when the economy weakens and we find people out of work," Seamans said.

Barretto, who is enrolled in a marketing certificate program at Santa Rosa Junior College, said she is relying on CalFresh to "get by while I can get back on my feet."

Her sons, Lawrence, 10, and Christopher, 8, have hearty appetites that consume her benefits in half a month or less. She shops at Safeway until the balance on her CalFresh electronic benefit transfer card is depleted, then heads to the Redwood Empire Food Bank for free groceries.

About one-fifth of the food bank's patrons receive CalFresh benefits, which last an average of 2.4 weeks, said Gail Atkins, director of programs at the nonprofit Santa Rosa-based food bank.

Atkins and Seamans said many eligible county residents do not apply for CalFresh, including Latinos who are wary of attention from immigration authorities and elders who don't bother because they consider the maximum benefit for a single person — $200 — too low.

Households with gross monthly income up to 130 percent of the federal poverty level — $1,211 for one person, $2,498 for four — are eligible for CalFresh.

Some legal immigrants qualify, as do children born in the United States to undocumented parents, who are ineligible.

John Hamner, 23, said he enrolled in CalFresh in July, a month after being laid off from work at a wine warehouse in Sonoma. He received $219 and thought it would feed him for a month, but his EBT card ran out with a week to go.

"Food is a huge expense," said Hamner, who has no permanent home and buys mostly microwavable food because he doesn't know how to cook.

"I appreciate what they're doing for me," Hamner said, although he noted Thursday that he has lost 10 pounds.

Sheri Holiday, 39, of Santa Rosa said CalFresh money goes further when she has a place to live and cook. She has received $190 to $200 a month from CalFresh for nearly two years.

Going hungry curbs her energy and depresses her, Holiday said, recalling times when she was homeless and without food stamps.

Holiday, who is single and unemployed, said she shops at Safeway, Grocery Outlet and the 99 Cents Only Store and has learned to "make healthier choices" on a limited budget.

In June, the House of Representatives rejected a measure that would have cut $20 billion from food stamps over 10 years and thrown nearly 2 million low-income people, mostly working families and the elderly, off the SNAP rolls.

The bill was defeated, with 62 Republicans joining Democrats opposed to cuts to the program. The Republicans primarily opposed the cuts as not steep enough.

A month later, the House approved a bill authorizing farm subsidies, but separating them from food stamps for the first time in history and leaving the SNAP program in limbo.

On Aug. 1, House Republican leaders announced a proposal to cut $40 billion from food stamps, dropping 4 million to 6 million people from the program, most of them unemployed childless adults.

In California, 346,000 of the 4.16 million who receive food stamps could lose benefits if the GOP proposal passes.

"The new proposal is stunningly harsh," said Robert Greenstein, president of the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities, a Washington, D.C.-based nonprofit group.

A Republican aide said the bill — due for consideration when the House resumes work in September — would include "common-sense measures, such as work requirements and job-training requirements for able-bodied adults without children."

Greenstein said the proposal was a "draconian benefit cutoff," questioning where millions of new jobs would be found in an economy that now creates 150,000 to 200,000 jobs a month. Despite recent gains, there are still 2 million fewer jobs than there were before the recession.

North Coast Rep. Jared Huffman, D-San Rafael, who voted against the first two bills, said the Republicans have opted to "double down on these irresponsible cuts" to nutrition programs.

"This is posturing, not legislating, and it will only make finalizing the farm bill more difficult," Huffman said in an email from the Middle East during the August congressional break.

Any food stamp legislation cleared by the House would have to be reconciled with the Senate farm bill, which cut only $4 billion from SNAP.

The proposed $40 billion cut is part of a Republican strategy to "press the (Obama) administration on domestic spending" with key fiscal decisions looming when the House goes back to work for nine days in September, said David McCuan, a Sonoma State University political scientist.

Liberals worry that social programs like food stamps "will be pitched off the lifeboat" as Obama strives for a grand bargain with the GOP on spending and the debt limit, he said.

John Handley, vice president of the California Independent Grocers Association, said the $40 billion cut is "way too harsh."

"We've always supported CalFresh," he said, describing it as a program that enables "financially challenged" people to buy nutritious food.

The association's 350 member stores, including six in Sonoma County, also benefit from the food-buying subsidy, a "win-win" for grocers and disadvantaged people, Handley said.

Regardless of what happens on Capitol Hill, SNAP recipients are facing a mandated benefits cut, effective Nov. 1, that reflects the expiration of federal emergency stimulus funding.

For a family of three such as Barretto's, the cut will amount to $29 a month, the equivalent of 16 meals a month, according to the budget and policy priorities center.

The November cut will reduce SNAP benefits by $5 billion in the next fiscal year, with California food stamp recipients losing $457 million during that period, the center said.

"These cuts will be particularly painful for the many families who struggle to have enough to eat at the end of each month even with SNAP assistance," said Stacy Dean of the budget center.

You can reach Staff Writer Guy Kovner at 521-5457 or guy.kovner@pressdemocrat.com.

UPDATED: Please read and follow our commenting policy:
  • This is a family newspaper, please use a kind and respectful tone.
  • No profanity, hate speech or personal attacks. No off-topic remarks.
  • No disinformation about current events.
  • We will remove any comments — or commenters — that do not follow this commenting policy.