FBI to investigate boy's death

The FBI is launching its own investigation into the shooting this week of Andy Lopez, the 13-year-old Santa Rosa boy killed by a Sonoma County sheriff's deputy who mistook the BB gun Lopez was holding for an assault rifle.

FBI officials notified command staff for Sheriff Steve Freitas and Santa Rosa Police Chief Tom Schwedhelm of the move Friday.

The federal inquiry is separate from the investigation led by Santa Rosa police into the deputy-involved shooting.

A spokesman in the FBI's San Francisco office called the agency's inquiry a "shooting review," looking into the "incident itself (and) the deputies' response."

"We're going to look into the facts of that," said Peter Lee, a public affairs specialist with the bureau. "It's a civil-rights type of case."

Both Schwedhelm and Freitas said they welcomed the additional inquiry. Both said they did not know exactly what the agency would be examining.

"I'm sure in the coming weeks they'll be in contact with us for information and we'll cooperate fully with them," Schwedhelm said.

The federal intervention is rare. The last time the FBI investigated a local officer-involved shooting was in the 1997 death of Kuan Chung Kao, a Taiwanese national killed by a Rohnert Park officer. The shooting enraged Chinese cultural groups, but the FBI investigation and separate state and local inquiries found insufficient evidence to file criminal charges.

Lopez's death has stirred perhaps even stronger community emotions.

He is the youngest person to die in an officer-involved shooting in Sonoma County, according to Press Democrat records stretching back to 1969.

Schwedhelm said the FBI, to his knowledge, had not played any role in the investigation led by his department into the Tuesday afternoon shooting.

A lieutenant in the police department fielded a call from the FBI notifying them of the agency's decision.

For Freitas, it was a sheriff's captain who got the word.

"They notified us what they were going to do and we said 'Great, we'll welcome that,' " Freitas said.

The sheriff said his office would also press ahead with its own internal investigation of the shooting.

Any finding by the FBI ultimately could wind up in the hands of the U.S. Attorney's Office.

The development could focus even greater attention on a rapidly evolving local story that has spurred a groundswell of community reaction, fueling daily marches and vigils, and drawn national and international attention, including the interest of the Mexican government.

Lopez, a Santa Rosa eighth-grader, was born in Sonoma County but his parents are from Sonora, Mexico.

He was shot seven times Tuesday on a sidewalk in southwest Santa Rosa by a veteran sheriff's deputy who reportedly mistook the plastic BB gun the boy was holding for an assault rifle.

Santa Rosa police are investigating the shooting under a long-standing local protocol that hands over such "critical incident" inquiries to a separate law enforcement agency.

Schwedhelm voiced confidence in his department's ability to complete a full and thorough inquiry.

"We're a professional policing organization," he said.

At the same time, citing "witnesses" interviewed in various media reports this week, Schwedhelm issued a plea to anyone who saw the shooting to come forward, saying his investigators want to talk to those people.

"We're following up on every investigative lead we have," he said.

Authorities declined Friday to provide answers to a number of questions about the final moments leading up to the shooting, at 3:14 p.m. in an unincorporated neighborhood of southwest Santa Rosa.

Investigators have yet to say whether or not the two deputies who drove up behind Lopez near Moorland and West Robles avenues identified themselves as law enforcement before ordering him to drop the gun. The boy initially had his back to the deputies when the orders were issued, police have indicated.

They also have yet to confirm whether the deputies had turned on their cruiser's siren before issuing the orders. A witness told police he thought he heard the chirp of the vehicle's siren, but the deputy at the controls "indicated that he wasn't sure if he'd turned the siren on or not," Santa Rosa Lt. Paul Henry said Friday.

Henry said he did not believe Lopez had any earphones or buds on at the time, but added Friday that he had not asked that specific question of investigators.

Lopez was described by police as wearing shorts and a "hoodie" sweatshirt at the time. Henry did not know if the hood on the garment was pulled up over the boy's head.

Police have said the deputies did not realize that Lopez was a juvenile at the time.

The veteran deputy who fired eight rounds at Lopez has 24 years with the Sheriff's Office. Of the seven bullets that struck the boy, two were fatal, according to an autopsy Thursday.

Police refused Friday to identify the type or model of service handgun used by the deputy or say how many rounds it held. They also have declined to release dispatch tapes of the incident.

"After talking with the district attorney, we're going to decline to provide any additional information at this time," Henry said Friday.

The other deputy involved at the scene was a recent hire with 11 years in law enforcement.

Authorities have declined to name either, citing death threats they say they are investigating against the deputies.

The most common civil rights complaints investigated by the FBI include allegations of excessive use of force by law enforcement personnel causing injuries or death, according to the agency's website.

Since 2000, 26 people have died in Sonoma County in officer-involved shootings, including five cases where officers' use of a Taser was linked to the deaths.

The Sheriff's Office or its deputies, who serve as police in Windsor and Sonoma, have been involved in 14 of the 26 fatal shootings since 2000.

Of those deaths, only one other case involved a teenager, 16-year-old Jeremiah Chass, an Analy High School student suffering a mental health crisis who was armed with a knife and engaged in a struggle with two sheriff's deputies, who shot him seven times.

The teen's family later settled their lawsuit against the county for $1.75 million.

Staff Writer Mary Callahan and News Researcher Janet Balicki contributed to this report.

UPDATED: Please read and follow our commenting policy:
  • This is a family newspaper, please use a kind and respectful tone.
  • No profanity, hate speech or personal attacks. No off-topic remarks.
  • No disinformation about current events.
  • We will remove any comments — or commenters — that do not follow this commenting policy.