Sonoma County task force readies proposal for civilian oversight of Sheriff’s Office
On the crest of a national movement to scrutinize police practices, Sonoma County is poised to create a form of civilian oversight for law enforcement.
The Board of Supervisors could soon start to fill in the details of a broad-brush proposal that would help open a window into policing practices and complaint investigations. A community task force has spent a year studying the successes and weaknesses of more than 200 such programs nationwide and will continue to gather community input as it hammers out the final recommendation it will give to the board, slated for next month.
Calls for civilian oversight of law enforcement are not new to Sonoma County, but the demands were renewed with the Oct. 22, 2013, shooting death of 13-year-old Andy Lopez by a deputy. Lopez was carrying an airsoft BB gun resembling an assault rifle as he walked to a friend’s house in his Moorland Avenue neighborhood on Santa Rosa’s outskirts.
The deputy called out for him to drop the gun, but the boy instead turned.
Lopez’ death triggered a broad set of reactions from the community including an instinctive recoil by people who have had troubling interactions with law enforcement. People - including hundreds of middle and high school-aged youth - took to the streets in repeated protests to demand that something change.
The auditor program could potentially provide the most tangible result.
“Talk to just about any adult of color in this county; you’ll find they’ve had a negative experience with law enforcement,” said professional chef Evelyn Cheatham, who is part of the task force that drafted the auditor plan. “Bringing an auditor office like this into the county shines a light on things, opens up the doors.”
The program has the potential to cost the county hundreds of thousands of dollars. But it could also provide an avenue for scrutiny of Sheriff’s Office practices from outside law enforcement that was not in place in 2013 when Lopez was killed. And it could create a forum for the public to air concerns and learn about law enforcement practices, one that didn’t exist when hundreds of schoolchildren left class and took to the streets to protest Lopez’s death.
While there are about 18,000 local law enforcement agencies nationwide, only about 200 have adopted civilian oversight. Some of the first were established decades ago amid the civil rights movement, and their impact varies widely.
Brian Buchner, president of the nonprofit National Association for Civilian Oversight of Law Enforcement, which advocates for oversight and advises how to do so, said that some of the most effective oversight programs actively dig into policing strategies and make recommendations.
“Are they identifying broken systems in the police department? Are their recommendations bringing about policy changes? What are the impact of the policy changes? How actively is the agency communicating information to the public?” Buchner said.
Since 2013, San Jose police officers have been documenting every time someone is temporarily detained, for example, when they are asked to sit on a curb and possibly put in handcuffs but then not arrested. Police began documenting temporary detentions in 2013, two years after the city’s police auditor recommended they start tracking the practice to get to the bottom of recurring community complaints of racial bias.
Similarly, BART’s police auditor and the police chief are collaborating this year to create a set of guidelines for how officers should interact with transgender people, including instructing officers to use the individual’s preferred pronoun regardless of the person’s appearance.
But other agencies have been less productive, have run into problems or struggled to assert themselves.
In Washington, King County’s first Office of Law Enforcement Oversight director resigned after three years on the job amid allegations of personality conflicts and harassment and filed a $1 million claim against the county.
Sausalito’s citizens’ advisory review board on police matters hasn’t met for at least a year. Philadelphia’s Police Advisory Commission built up a massive backlog of complaint investigations and, according to local news reports, did not make a recommendation to the Police Department from 2007 until 2012.
Police commissions, auditors, citizen review boards, inspector generals, civilian monitors and other formats have varying levels of power. Some are empowered by legal authority, while others use political influence to get things done.
After more than a year of sometimes-contentious public meetings, the Community and Local Law Enforcement Task Force formed after Lopez’s death will go before the Board of Supervisors and propose an Office of Independent Auditor that would review policies and internal complaint investigations against Sheriff’s Office personnel, probation officers and correctional officers. The auditor would serve as an ombudsman for police-community relations. Citizen and youth advisory boards would foster community involvement.
UPDATED: Please read and follow our commenting policy: