A divided Windsor Town Council has awarded the town’s garbage collection contract to a new company despite complaints from other bidders that the process was unfair and likely to be challenged in court.
On a 3-2 vote late Wednesday, the council assigned the hauling contract for the next 10 years to Green Waste Recovery Inc., with a majority of the council citing the lower rates and environmental practices of the San-Jose based company.
Mayor Debora Fudge said the council shouldn’t “cave in” to the threat of a lawsuit from critics or “we’re playing right into their hands.”
But council members who dissented raised concerns over Green Waste’s plans for a proposed transfer station in Petaluma for recycled materials that is not yet permitted.
A Green Waste representative assured the council the company is confident of being able to get the necessary permits by Sept. 30 — when the current garbage contract expires — to turn a church property at 879 and 901 Lindberg Ave., Petaluma, into a facility for transferring containers with recyclable materials to bigger trucks for a longer haul to San Jose.
“The issue in Petaluma bothers me,” said Councilman Bruce Okrepkie, who said he was concerned with the permitting process, not the threat of legal action.
Councilman Dominic Foppoli said he was bothered that Green Waste withdrew partway through the life of its hauling contract with Petaluma, despite the positive comments Wednesday from Petaluma Mayor David Glass who said Green Waste was “first class” and delivered “really good service.”
But a majority of the council chose Green Waste, citing lower rates, educational outreach to customers, as well as its low carbon footprint, including a plant near Gilroy that extracts energy from food waste to power its processing operations.
Windsor’s bidding is being closely watched by Santa Rosa because many of the same players and issues have been involved in both municipalities’ searches for a new hauler.
The Ratto Group, the same company that holds Windsor’s expiring contract, also has a contract with Santa Rosa that runs out at the end of the year.
Santa Rosa narrowed the field of bidders down to two finalists: Green Waste, and Waste Management, the nation’s largest garbage firm.
Rattling a legal saber at Windsor’s meeting on Wednesday was an environmental law firm that is demanding a full environmental review of the various proposals the town has received for its garbage contract.
Attorney Richard Drury, representing Petaluma River Council and Community Science Institute, said homes sit within 600 feet of the Lindberg Avenue facility, and there will be odors and other impacts that need more study.
The Lindberg property is south of Target and the East Washington Place shopping center.
It would serve as a recycling transfer station, with material directly transferred from one covered vehicle to another, to be taken to San Jose for sorting. Garbage would be taken to the county landfill west of Cotati.
Drury raised similar objections last month to a transfer facility Green Waste was contemplating building on an industrial parcel on West Robles Avenue in Santa Rosa.
Green Waste subsequently announced it was dropping its option to buy that site and instead was settling on Petaluma.
Santa Rosa Junior College
Sonoma State University
Alexander Valley Union (Healdsburg)
Alexander Valley School
Bellevue Union (Santa Rosa)
Meadow View School
Taylor Mountain School
Eagle Creek Community Day School
Johanna Echols-Hansen Continuation High School
Cotati-Rohnert Park Unified (Cotati/Rohnert Park)
El Camino High School
Evergreen Elementary School
Hahn (Marguerite) Elementary School
Lawrence E. Jones Middle School
Monte Visa Elementary School
Page (Thomas) Academy
Rancho Cotate High School
Rohnert (Waldo) Intermediate School
Technology High School
Technology Middle School
Phoenix High School
Fort Ross School
Buena Vista High
Gravenstein Union (Sebastopol)
Gravenstein Community Day School
Harmony Union (Occidental)
Salmon Creek Charter
Healdsburg Charter School, Fitch Mountain/HES Campuses
Healdsburg Elementary School, Fitch Mountain/HES Campuses
Healdsburg Junior High
Marce Becerra Academy
Liberty Primary/Elementary School
Monte Rio Union
Monte Rio School
Oak Grove Union (West Santa Rosa/Sebastopol)
Oak Grove Elementary
Petaluma City Schools
Live Oak Charter
Santa Rosa City Schools
Castle Preschool and Afterschool
Brook Haven School
Park Side School
REACH Charter School
Twin Hills Union (Sebastopol)
Apple Blossom School
Orchard View School
Twin Hills Middle
Two Rock Union (Petaluma)
Two Rock School
Waugh School District (Petaluma)
Corona Creek School
Westside Union District (Healdsburg)
Westside Union Elementary
West Sonoma County Union High (Forestville/Sebastopol)
El Molino High
WSCUHSD Community Day School
Windsor Unified (Windsor)
Cali Calmecac Language Academy
Mattie Washburn Elementary
Windsor Creek Elementary
Windsor Oaks Academy
Village Charter School, Santa Rosa
Greenacres School (Sebastopol)
Journey High School (Sebastopol)
New Horizons School (Santa Rosa)
Plumfield Academy (Sebastopol)
Anderson Valley Unified
Fort Bragg Unified
Leggett Valley including Whale Gulch
Point Arena/Arena Schools
Upper Lake Elementary
Upper Lake High
LCOE schools (Hance and Creativity)