PD Editorial: Prop. 47 is investment in future savings

  • TOM MEYER / meyertoons.com

It costs about $50,000 a year to lock someone up in a California prison or a county jail — more than 10 times the state’s per-pupil expenditure for public education.

Despite investing hundreds of billions of dollars in new prisons and jails over the past 30 years, California’s correctional facilities are crowded beyond capacity. The state is under a federal court order to reduce its prison population. And after assuming more responsibility for corrections, many counties are releasing inmates early, either under court orders or self-imposed caps on jail crowding.

Building prisons isn’t the answer. But putting fewer people behind bars might alleviate the problem.

Some experts have argued for years that a small investment in education, mental health and crime prevention programs would produce big savings on incarceration. But that’s a long-term strategy in a state with upwards of 190,000 inmates in its prisons and jails.

So the state corrections budget climbed to $9 billion a year. Meanwhile, cheered on by police, prosecutors and the union representing the state’s prison guards, voters and legislators enacted increasingly harsh sentences — and not just for violent crimes. That fueled the need for new prisons and a costly culture of recidivism.

There’s an opportunity to try prevention on a wide scale.

Proposition 47 on the Nov. 4 ballot would reduce sentences by redefining several nonviolent offenses as misdemeanors, including petty theft, receiving stolen property, writing bad checks and simple possession of drugs. About 40,000 people are convicted of those offenses annually .

Shorter sentences would result in savings of several hundred million dollars a year for state and local governments, the state’s nonpartisan legislative analyst said.

Proposition 47 earmarks 90 percent of those savings for truancy prevention and mental health and substance abuse treatment — programs that keep people out of the justice system by helping them lead productive lives. The rest of the savings would go to programs for crime victims.

The initiative is sponsored by former San Diego police Chief Bill Landsdowne and George Gascon, the district attorney and former police chief in San Francisco.

comments powered by Disqus
© The Press Democrat |  Terms of Service |  Privacy Policy |  Jobs With Us |  RSS |  Advertising |  Sonoma Media Investments |  Place an Ad
Switch to our Mobile View