Morain: Despite green work, billionaire faces access fight

  • File - In this Feb. 10, 2014, file photo, Julie Graves, left, of Albany, Calif., and Chris Adams, second from left, of Berkeley, Calif., hold up signs in support of a beach access bill that Democratic state Sen. Jerry Hill introduced near Martin's Beach in Half Moon Bay, Calif. California's Coastal Commission is asking the public to document its use of Martin's Beach after billionaire landowner Vinod Khosla closed the only access road to it. (AP Photo/Eric Risberg, File)

As billionaires go, Vinod Khosla would seem to be an unlikely villain for environmentalists. He donated more than $1 million to help re-elect President Barack Obama; $2 million for a 2006 initiative that sought to tax oil; and $1 million to kill an oil industry proposition that tried to roll back Assembly Bill 32, the law that is forcing the state to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.

Khosla Ventures’ website describes its leader as “driven by the desire to make a positive impact through scaling new energy sources, achieving petroleum independence and promoting a pragmatic approach to the environment.”

The Sand Hill Road venture capital firm’s portfolio includes EcoMotors, which is “redefining how the world is powered”; Climate Corp., which “aims to help farmers around the world protect and improve their farming operations”; and LanzaTech, which “uses a novel biological approach to transform industrial carbon rich waste gases and residues into fuels and chemicals.”

Still, if Khosla thought his past work might have given him a pass, he definitely was mistaken. He finds himself being vilified by environmentalists who accuse him of locking them out of a stretch of San Mateo County coastline.

In 2008, Khosla bought 53 acres south of Half Moon Bay for $32.5 million from a family that had held it since the early 1900s. It’s known as Martins Beach.

Based on the pictures, it’s a beautiful spot; there’s a rock a short distance offshore that looks like a shark’s tooth. The cove would be an ideal place for a family compound, though Khosla has not submitted development plans to that effect.

Billionaires do like coastal property, and some of them don’t much like to share, as the less privileged people of Malibu not named Geffen, Katzenberg and Ellison have found.

San Mateo County officials annoyed Khosla in 2009, and he closed the gate, restricting access to the easement that leads to Martins Beach. Environmentalists responded by accusing him of denying them their rights granted by God and the California constitution to walk along the lovely cove.

The Surfrider Foundation, among others, sued to force him to let them get to the beach to ride the surf, and Sen. Jerry Hill, a San Mateo County Democrat, carried legislation that also would force open access. His Senate Bill 968 urges the state Lands Commission to negotiate with Khosla to provide access to Martins Beach and says, if negotiations fail, the commission would seek to buy the easement in an eminent domain action.

As happens when disputes spill into the Legislature and the courts, what is real becomes relative. But both sides agree that Khosla is raising a property rights issue that, in the right lawyers’ hands, could end up before the Supreme Court of the United States.

comments powered by Disqus
© The Press Democrat |  Terms of Service |  Privacy Policy |  Jobs With Us |  RSS |  Advertising |  Sonoma Media Investments |  Place an Ad
Switch to our Mobile View