From malls to gas pumps, TVs are becoming a ubiquitous part of local retail landscape; are consumers facing information overload?

The "Follow This Story" feature will notify you when any articles related to this story are posted.

When you follow a story, the next time a related article is published — it could be days, weeks or months — you'll receive an email informing you of the update.

If you no longer want to follow a story, click the "Unfollow" link on that story. There's also an "Unfollow" link in every email notification we send you.

This tool is available only to subscribers; please make sure you're logged in if you want to follow a story.

Please note: This feature is available only to subscribers; make sure you're logged in if you want to follow a story.


Judy Watten was having trouble concentrating on "The Call of the Wild." Dr. Phil kept interrupting her thoughts.

"It's frustrating as hell," the Kenwood woman said, sitting on a bench inside Santa Rosa Plaza with a copy of Jack London's classic in her hands. "Do they not want us to read books?"

Above Watten, Dr. Phil's familiar visage beamed across a large flat-screen TV. The pop psychologist spoke about living one's beliefs, his words echoing the length of the mall where 20 TVs created a miasma of sight and sound.

The high-definition Samsungs represent the latest invasion of video into public places once considered off-limits to TV. Many grocery stores, airports, banks, elevators - even gasoline pumps - now broadcast programming mostly geared toward selling stuff.

Stung by technologies, such as TiVo and the Internet, which allow people to skip or ignore ads, marketers are bringing television directly to consumers in the places where they shop, lounge, bank or fill up, a trend some applaud and others go haywire over.

"It's unstoppable," said Simon Badinter, chairman and chief executive at the Medias and Regies Europe and North American unit of Publicis, the world's fourth-largest advertising company. "I think people want to be entertained and clients want to reach shoppers at the point of sale."

Publicis has partnered with the Simon Property Group, the nation's largest owner of shopping malls, including Santa Rosa Plaza, to create the OnSpot Digital Network.

The network is aimed at getting people to pay attention to ads at the moment when they are most primed to make a purchase.

A 30-second commercial on an estimated 2,000 screens in 50 malls costs $350,000 a month, which likely rules out the possibility of local content. Sprinkled in with the ads are light features on fashion, entertainment and lifestyles.

The strategy appears to work: An Arbitron study found 41 percent of customers said they made unexpected purchases after hearing in-store messages.

"We got a very good feel from consumers embracing this technology," said Stewart Stockdale, Simon's chief marketing officer. "Our primary focus is to enhance the shopping experience and the research was very positive."

The company tested sound levels on the TVs to make them more "complementary" with the ambient noise in the mall, Stockdale said.

On the morning Watten read a book while waiting for a friend to finish shopping, the TV noise inside the relatively deserted Santa Rosa mall overwhelmed other sounds. But on Friday, when the throngs filled the space, the TVs emitted no sound at all.

One might argue that TVs are a natural fit in malls, which already are meccas to advertising, some of it loud and garish. But as TVs creep into a wide array of public places, some consumers complain about sensory overload and unwanted advances from the digital world.

At Albertson's grocery stores, large TVs loom over the produce and deli sections. Smaller, and much harder to ignore, screens are at each checkstand.

"We're bombarded," said a woman outside the Montgomery Village Albertson's who identified herself as Ladonne. "I stay out of the mall, and I shop at Whole Foods most of the time."

Older adults in general seemed less pleased with the new technology, compared with younger people who've grown up with video games, the Internet and iPods.

"There's nothing being forced down my throat," said Brian Elias, 20, of Rohnert Park who ate lunch in the Santa Rosa Plaza's food court, where six TVs stare down on diners.

"I'm pretty sure in 30 years the latest technology is going to bother me, too," said Zack Lyon, 21, who was seated at the same table.

So how much is too much?

By 2011, 90 percent of retailers are expected to have in-store digital screens, according to the market-research company Frost & Sullivan. Ad revenue, in the meantime, is expected to reach $3.7 billion, up from $102 million in 2004.

Virginia Cargill, president and chief executive officer of SignStorey, a Connecticut-based company that offers programming in 1,300 grocery stores nationwide, said grocers so far have balked at placing TVs on aisles or in front of individual products, fearing that could turn customers away.

"That's why it's on the perimeter," she said. "Anything that is added will be added after we get consumer reaction."

Ed Palmer, a professor of psychology at Davidson College in North Carolina, said companies are able to send text messages to customers as they walk past their stores, using GPS technology and previously collected information about their shopping habits.

His concern is that consumers are not being given enough time to reflect before making a purchase. He said his research into television's affect on children also revealed too much tube time can lead to mental health problems, including depression.

"It's an intrusion into my space," Palmer said. "I didn't ask for it. I didn't invite it. But it's there."

Stockdale, however, said he's not worried the TVs in Simon properties will detract from what he referred to as the mall's "town square" atmosphere.

"These loops last eight to 10 minutes," he said. "They're part of the environment. People will still do what they do."

Show Comment

Our Network

Sonoma Index-Tribune
Petaluma Argus Courier
North Bay Business Journal
Sonoma Magazine
Bite Club Eats
La Prensa Sonoma
Emerald Report
Spirited Magazine