Kaiser study details vaccine hesitancy in Sonoma County

The "Follow This Story" feature will notify you when any articles related to this story are posted.

When you follow a story, the next time a related article is published — it could be days, weeks or months — you'll receive an email informing you of the update.

If you no longer want to follow a story, click the "Unfollow" link on that story. There's also an "Unfollow" link in every email notification we send you.

This tool is available only to subscribers; please make sure you're logged in if you want to follow a story.

Please note: This feature is available only to subscribers; make sure you're logged in if you want to follow a story.


A newly released study of Northern California Kaiser patients confirms Sonoma County’s position in the ranks of California regions with high rates of childhood vaccine refusal and youngsters who are missing one or more of the immunizations recommended by the time they reach age 3.

Amid rising concern among medical professionals about a growing culture of vaccine hesitancy nationwide and the resurgence of health threats such as measles and pertussis, or whooping cough, the study identified five geographic areas in Northern California where parental delay or refusal of immunizations are clustered.

The largest by far is an area taking in parts of Sonoma and Napa counties, where 17.5 percent of young patients lacked at least one of the 17 shots recommended for children by 36 months of age, according to the study released today in the medical journal Pediatrics.

It’s not news that Sonoma and Marin counties, in particular, have high numbers of parents choosing to reject some or all of the vaccines commonly given to children in their first years of life.

One Sebastopol couple said Monday it’s a reflection of some parents’ refusal to accept anything at face value without careful examination, when it comes to the lives of their children.

In some areas of west Sonoma County, 1 in 5 children entering kindergarten have obtained personal belief exemptions waiving vaccine requirements, according to past school records. Two Sebastopol-area districts, Twin Hills Union Elementary and Sebastopol Union Elementary, have reported personal belief exemption rates of 40 percent or higher in recent years.

But researchers say the study demonstrates the possibility of using medical records to track vaccination trends in real time and provide information to help focus medical outreach and, potentially, surveillance for outbreaks of disease.

“I think there’s really strong evidence that areas where there are high under-immunization, there is a higher risk of disease outbreak,” especially very contagious ones like measles and pertussis, said Tracy A. Lieu, lead author of the study.

“It’s not just the individual children who have missed their vaccines,” she continued. “It’s a risk that increases for other children even when they are vaccinated.”

The study also is useful in-house because it may help Kaiser doctors tailor education about vaccinations to boost success toward reaching established immunization benchmarks, researchers said. The study was released to the wider medical community because of its implications outside of Kaiser, Lieu said.

The study used electronic medical records for young patients of Kaiser Permanente of Northern California, which included 154,424 children living in 13 counties in and around the Bay Area and the Central Valley, who were born between Jan. 1, 2000, and Dec. 31, 2009.

Any child who missed at least one of the 17 vaccinations recommended by the Centers of Disease Control by 36 months of age was considered “under-immunized.”

The 10-year study also considered whether the parent or parents had declined all vaccinations or were “shot limiting,” meaning a child received all the recommended doses but never more than two at once.

The results showed that high under-immunization rates cluster geographically, with rates of unvaccinated children running between 17.5 percent and 22.7 percent in the five defined areas, compared with 11 percent outside them, during the most recent period, 2010-2012.

The under-immunization clusters included an area about 29 miles wide straddling Sonoma and Napa counties, a small East Bay area between Richmond and San Leandro; another between Sacramento and Roseville; an area covering northern San Francisco and southern Marin County; and a very small area in Vallejo.

During years 2006-2009, when under-immunization clustered differently, western Sonoma County stood well out from the 10-year data, with a 30 percent rate, according to the study.

Overall, rates in the 13-county area rose over the decade, starting at 8.1 percent in the 2002-2005 time-frame and reaching 12.4 percent in the 2010-2012 period, the study says.

Kaiser Santa Rosa pediatrician Corina Glover said a worldwide decline in vaccination rates followed the 1998 publication of a now-debunked study linking the mumps/measles/rubella vaccine with autism. Though the study was refuted, retracted and ultimately determined to be fraudulent, fear of the alleged autism connection lingers, she said.

But there are multiple reasons parents decline to vaccinate their children — from small amounts of aluminum and other metals historically used as vaccine preservatives, to potential side effects, to concerns that the recommended schedule risks overloading the immune system of an infant or young child, Glover said.

In any of those cases, it’s a sign of the parents’ deep desire to do right by their child that drives them, “so I think that’s a really good thing,” Glover said. “That tells me they really care a lot.”

But what’ s often missing, Glover said, is a clear understanding of the science. Aluminum occurs naturally in the Earth’s crust, as well as food, water, even breast milk, she said.

There’s a limited risk of side effects from most vaccines, she said, but the trade-offs are diseases that once took thousands of lives every year and left others with bleak consequences.

Right now, those who don’t choose vaccination can largely do so and get a “free ride” because most do vaccinate. But there’s a threshold for each disease at which a community loses its “herd immunity” when enough decline vaccines and that illness begins gaining strength, as has been happening in recent years with measles and pertussis, she said.

A Sebastopol pair who raised two kids, giving them some vaccinations but not others, said it was their right and responsibility to evaluate each immunization singly, in consultation with their family doctor, taking into account the risk of side effects, the risk of being exposed to the disease and other considerations, like preservatives.

The couple did not want their names published because of the intense debate swirling in their community, and even within their extended family, but said they tried to walk a “middle road” that was not about fear, but about reasoned judgment.

They said they took into account the fact that they have medical coverage, are careful, observant parents, and are skeptical of corporate interests at play in the vaccine debate.

“I think most parents are just really concerned,” one of them said, “trying to do the right thing, and asking tough questions, and making decisions.”

You can reach Staff Writer Mary Callahan at 521-5249 or mary.callahan@pressdemocrat.com. On Twitter @MaryCallahanB.

Show Comment

Our Network

Sonoma Index-Tribune
Petaluma Argus Courier
North Bay Business Journal
Sonoma Magazine
Bite Club Eats
La Prensa Sonoma
Emerald Report
Spirited Magazine