German refugee welcome contrasts with cold reception in '90s
BERLIN — Crowds greet trainloads of migrants with applause, candy and toys. A provincial town's mayor wants to take in more refugees. Top conservative politicians say Germany needs young immigrants.
It's a contrast with a frosty reception when migrant arrivals in Germany last spiked in the 1990s and mainstream politicians rushed to tighten asylum rules, while the country's top-selling newspaper asked: "The flood is rising — when will the boat sink?"
Germany expects 800,000 new migrants to arrive this year, nearly twice the previous record. And while attacks on homes for refugees and anti-migrant protests have caused widespread alarm, the broader atmosphere has been strikingly welcoming — illustrated by the weekend's euphoric scenes in stations from Bavarian metropolis Munich to provincial Saalfeld in which throngs of Germans greeted migrants.
The previous record dates back to 1992, when nearly 440,000 asylum-seekers came as the former Yugoslavia disintegrated — coinciding with a spate of anti-foreigner attacks that shamed Germany.
In perhaps the most notorious incident back then, days of rioting in the eastern city of Rostock saw far-right extremists throw firebombs and stones at a center for refugees, then a neighboring apartment block inhabited by Vietnamese immigrants, as bystanders cheered.
In contrast to the Bild daily's 1992 headline about a sinking boat, the newspaper today has taken a pro-refugee line. A recent Sunday edition led with seven pages of supportive messages from prominent Germans under the headline "100 voices against hatred of refugees."
"We stood on the edge of a moral abyss ... and we have moved on as a society," said Christoph Rass, an expert on contemporary history at the University of Osnabrueck's Institute for Migration Research and Intercultural Studies. Previous generations of immigrants have found their place in society, Germany has become more prosperous and racism is no longer "socially acceptable" in the way it was back then, he said.
Ordinary Germans have been pitching in lately to help refugees. Many went over the weekend to Munich's main station, bringing everything from water to toiletries, as trains with refugees arrived. On Sunday, police tweeted that no more donations were needed at the station, then called for people to donate men's clothing and shoes to a city refugee shelter. Within three hours, no more of those were needed either.
Chancellor Angela Merkel says she is "proud and grateful to see how countless people in Germany are reacting to the arrival of the refugees."
These days, politicians stress that the boat isn't full — in fact, it threatens to get worryingly empty due to a demographic crisis brought on by a low birth rate. Increasingly, leaders portray the wave of migrants as an opportunity for Europe's biggest economy. As it stands, deaths outpace births, and the government's statistical office said earlier this year that it expects the population of 80.8 million to shrink by a tenth or more by 2060.
"We are a country of immigration. We need people. We need young people. We need immigrants," Interior Minister Thomas de Maiziere told visitors to a recent government open day event. "All of you know that, because we have too few children."
Oliver Junk, the mayor of Goslar in central Germany, has drawn attention by saying that his town of 50,000 — with a dwindling population and empty housing — could take in more refugees. He argues that "towns like Goslar have no chance without a long-term influx" of people.
De Maiziere's description of Germany as a "country of immigration" would have been hard to imagine from a leading conservative politician only 15 years ago.
A bitter 1999 state election campaign centered on a conservative drive against allowing dual citizenship for many residents with foreign roots. The following year, an unsuccessful candidate to be governor of Germany's most populous state used the slogan "Kinder statt Inder," or "children, not Indians" to argue that Germany should step up its own education rather than bring in foreign computer experts.
Politicians' response to rising asylum applications in the 1990s was "too many are coming, we'll solve the problem by limiting the right to asylum, then it's dealt with and everyone can sleep easy," said Orkan Kosemen, an expert on integration at the Bertelsmann Foundation think-tank. When refugee centers were attacked at the time, there were candlelight vigils and help campaigns but "the majority was indifferent," he said.
An immigration law approved in 2004 sought to balance Germany's need to attract qualified migrants with concerns about matters such as their integration, mandating government-funded German language and civics courses for newcomers.
UPDATED: Please read and follow our commenting policy: