Nevius: Time for the Giants to think beyond Bruce Bochy

The "Follow This Story" feature will notify you when any articles related to this story are posted.

When you follow a story, the next time a related article is published — it could be days, weeks or months — you'll receive an email informing you of the update.

If you no longer want to follow a story, click the "Unfollow" link on that story. There's also an "Unfollow" link in every email notification we send you.

This tool is available only to subscribers; please make sure you're logged in if you want to follow a story.

Please note: This feature is available only to subscribers; make sure you're logged in if you want to follow a story.


Honestly, it is hard to imagine a world where Bruce Bochy is the manager of the Giants next year.

Back-to-back disappointing seasons is not how this franchise sees itself. Their mindset is “perennial contender.”

And since the results aren’t cutting it, we know the brain trust will not be patient. This week Grant Cohn advanced the idea in a column on that this year should be Bochy’s last, and although the die-hards howled, I agree.

The only thing I’d say is it would be nice to get buy-in from Bochy so he could announce his departure as the season winds down and accept the grateful appreciation of Giants fans.

It is not the big move the Giants probably had in mind for 2019. They’ve been assiduously staying under the salary limit to limit their luxury-tax bill. The idea is to have cash available to chase a marquee free agent. And let’s all say “Bryce Harper” in unison.

But I’d say a change at manager is the bigger move.

There is no simpler and quicker way to change the culture and mood of a baseball team than to put a new guy in the manager’s office. He makes dozens of calls every day — from writing out the lineup to managing the bullpen — and each directly affects individual players.

And the Giants definitely need a change in mood and culture.

Not that Bochy hasn’t had big moments. He won three World Series in a place that — when previous World Series chances ended in bitter, unlikely defeats — seemed cursed never to win one. He’s been Manager of the Year twice. It has become automatic to say he will be in the Hall of Fame.

And for all I know, Bochy gives rousing clubhouse speeches that have the players ready to run through sheets of concrete for him.

It just hasn’t looked like it for the last two seasons.

So it says here he is unlikely to be back. And, if the Giants need a new manager, they have two directions to go.

First, they can promote from within and then use their time and treasure to pursue some glittering star. We hear complicated trade proposals that would send some of our favorite Giants away in exchange for the next Barry Bonds.

Just sayin’, those deals are tough to pull off and success is iffy.

Or, they can make the new manager the big deal.

I’ve come around on this management/coach/guru position. I used to think it was overrated.

But guys like Steve Kerr at the Warriors or Kyle Shanahan at the 49ers — heck, even the Raiders’ Jon Gruden — aren’t just drawing X’s and O’s. They are creating a team culture, a way of doing things.

I’m sure the Giants are thoroughly sick and tired of comparisons to the Oakland A’s, but what’s one more? The Giants clubhouse is a somber, formal place where players pad around quietly and rarely make eye contact. Meanwhile, the A’s rock their basement clubhouse.

Another writer mentioned the “energy,” and that’s a good call. The players are fired up and happy to chat. (Of course, winning and becoming baseball’s darlings helps.) That’s missing in S.F.

I’ve probably already outed myself as a fan of A’s manager Bob Melvin, so I may as well go full advocate for the Giants’ job. He’s local — high school in Atherton and a year at Cal. He’s experienced — this year he won his 1,000th career game. If he wins Manager of the Year this season (and he’s got to be a front-runner) it will be his third, having already won one in the National League and one in the American.

Coincidently, like Bochy, Melvin has one year left on his contract after this.

And OK, maybe the Giants won’t sign Melvin. Maybe they insist on promoting from within the organization. Maybe they still hold a grudge for the A’s. Maybe there’s a secret plan.

And granted, the team is going to have to address the roster. But another round of rearrange- the-deck-chairs-and- sign-a-30-year-old-free-agent is not going to fly with the paying customers.

Now, wouldn’t a managerial search set off a whirlwind of speculation, rumors and wild guesses?

You bet. Which, I’d submit, is great.

The Giants will be the center of attention. There would be discussion of what kind of guy they’d bring in. Names would be floated and recommendations made.

And then, once he was hired, he’d sit down and sketch out his vision for the future. Which, I guarantee you, we media types will buy into — hook, line and sinker — because that’s how it works with new managers. And it works until there is evidence to the contrary.

Players would have to suss out how the new guy plans to use them. Media folks would have to get used to a new interview style. Fans would appraise his strategic moves to see if they like his approach.

Which, I’d submit again, is great.

The Giants have the unmistakable look of a team that needs a shakeup. They need more home runs, of course, but they also need an infusion of pep, confidence and energy.

That comes from putting a new guy in charge who encourages and fosters pep, confidence and energy.

Or maybe they are going to swing for the fences with a blockbuster trade for the next Barry Bonds.

Good luck with that.

Contact C.W. Nevius at Twitter: @cwnevius

Show Comment

Our Network

Sonoma Index-Tribune
Petaluma Argus Courier
North Bay Business Journal
Sonoma Magazine
Bite Club Eats
La Prensa Sonoma
Emerald Report
Spirited Magazine