Barber: NFL, NBA, MLB preseasons, ranked

The "Follow This Story" feature will notify you when any articles related to this story are posted.

When you follow a story, the next time a related article is published — it could be days, weeks or months — you'll receive an email informing you of the update.

If you no longer want to follow a story, click the "Unfollow" link on that story. There's also an "Unfollow" link in every email notification we send you.

This tool is available only to subscribers; please make sure you're logged in if you want to follow a story.

Please note: This feature is available only to subscribers; make sure you're logged in if you want to follow a story.


The NFL preseason is winding down. The NHL preseason begins in three weeks, the NBA preseason in a little more than a month. Even Major League Baseball spring training is in the news as everyone tries to determine whether Buster Posey’s hip will be mended by the time mitts start popping in 2019.

It’s an appropriate time to compare the preseason action of the various pro sports leagues. Or even rank them:

1. MLB

Spring training isn’t Baseball Lite or a prologue to the real game. It’s an entity unto itself, and not necessarily an inferior one. It is a more casual, more intimate, more nostalgic version of the MLB season to follow, and it is strangely beautiful.

Yes, split squads are weird, and as in other sports you are, in part, watching players who won’t figure largely in the team’s plans that season. But baseball separates itself with an emphasis on individuality. You can take a pitcher like Mike Fiers, send him from Detroit to Oakland in August, plug him into his new surroundings, and it’s like the only thing that has changed is the uniform. He’s the same Mike Fiers.

Likewise, when you’re watching Madison Bumgarner or Matt Chapman in the spring, they are mostly their real selves. You know they might be working on a certain pitch or fiddling with the batting stance. Their statistics don’t mean much. But they aren’t as reliant on scheme or the play of teammates as basketball and football players are. March Bumgarner doesn’t look all that different from August Bumgarner.

More than that, the format of spring training is a delight. Preseason ball in a regular-season stadium feels bush league. MLB avoids the hollowness by moving everything off-site and clustering professional clubs like Little League teams.

It’s brilliant. A little baseball vacation in Phoenix for chilled-to-the-bone Brewers fans? Yes, please! And the baseball parks of Arizona and Florida aren’t cheaper, smaller versions of MLB parks. They are little pieces of Americana with old-fashioned advertisements on the outfield wall and fans close enough to the action (and modest enough in number) that Bryce Harper can hear their taunts.

MLB’s opening day brings some jitters to die-hard baseball fans. But when was the last time you heard someone complaining that spring training was dragging on forever?

2. NHL

Full disclosure: I’ve never seen an NHL preseason game. Sorry. But it has to be better than…

3. NBA

The NBA tries to have it both ways, with Summer League games featuring young, developing players and preseason games with full squads. The full package is pretty meh.

Summer League has its moments, especially when the games move to Las Vegas. But you have to be a real basketball addict to get hyped about Warriors games in which the standout players are Marcus Derrickson and J.P. Tokoto. It’s strictly for wonks.

The true NBA preseason isn’t dreadful. Basketball doesn’t have the same plug-and-play, every-man-for-himself quality as baseball, but individuals do stand out as they show off their skills. And the big names play in the first half of October. Stephen Curry averaged 24 minutes in four preseason games last year; Kevin Durant averaged 19. If you plunk down money for an NBA preseason game, you will see the stars doing their thing.

The problem is that no-stakes basketball is fairly terrible. The players look like they’re just going through the motions. That isn’t a problem in baseball, because half of baseball IS going through motions — getting the sign from the catcher, adjusting the batting gloves, getting a new ball from the umpire after a foul tip. Basketball demands more energy, and preseason games don’t deliver it.

One great thing about the NBA preseason: It’s blessedly short. The Warriors will play just five practice games this year.

4. NFL

Take those other preseasons and jam them through a sieve that filters out all of the fun, and you have the NFL in August. Half-assed football in half-filled stadiums that keeps us half-interested, at best.

The Hall of Fame Game, the NFL’s annual kickoff, comes upon us like a freak hailstorm when it’s 100 degrees outside and we’re on our way to the beach. It’s too soon. It’s all wrong for the violent game of football.

The sidelines are bloated with names you didn’t know before, and will have forgotten in two months. The rosters are so big that they have to double up some jersey numbers. It’s not uncommon to have two guys on the same team both wearing No. 47, running side by side as they chase a punt returner.

The big problem lies in football’s complexity. It’s simply impossible to showcase a Jimmy Garoppolo or a Marshawn Lynch in a vacuum. He must be surrounded with 10 teammates, all of whom are trying to execute precise assignments in tight coordination. By October, they get there and it’s a thing of beauty. In August it is frequently a clown show of dropped snaps, penalties and pratfalls.

The intricacy of the plays, combined with the legendary paranoia of football coaches, results in slimmed-down playbooks from which many of the Xs and Os have been redacted. Preseason football is an endless loop of off-tackle runs and screen passes.

And so the games are interminable. The Raiders-Packers contest I attended Friday night officially ran 3 hours, 14 minutes. But it felt as though they were playing for days, Connor Cook matching DeShone Kizer incompletion for incompletion until they had to give up the field because the A’s were returning from a road trip.

There’s no denying it. The NFL preseason is a travesty. The good news? It will be over in another week. Also, pitchers and catchers report in 173 days.

You can reach columnist Phil Barber at 707-521-5263 or Follow him on Twitter: @Skinny_Post.

Show Comment

Our Network

Sonoma Index-Tribune
Petaluma Argus Courier
North Bay Business Journal
Sonoma Magazine
Bite Club Eats
La Prensa Sonoma
Emerald Report
Spirited Magazine