Enrique Lopez heard the pitch before — PG&E is to blame for the October firestorm that destroyed his Santa Rosa home. And the massive San Francisco utility should pay for it.
The Coffey Park resident listened to the presentation in a hotel ballroom as a group of lawyers from San Diego explained over free pizza their plans to sue for uninsured losses expected to climb into the billions of dollars.
They handed out contingency agreements and asked each of the dozen or so fire victims for their business.
Lopez, a vineyard manager who has been to at least one other similar meeting, decided to keep looking.
“We’re shopping around,” said Lopez as he stood in a Santa Rosa Courtyard Marriott hallway with his partner, disability attorney Cherri Alcantara. “We still haven’t found anyone.”
Lopez is among the hundreds of fire victims considering their legal options in the wake of Northern California fires that burned 245,000 acres in six counties, killed 44 people and caused more than $9 billion in damage claims.
Although Cal Fire says it may be months before it knows how the fires started, lawyers from across the country are already courting fire victims in a high-stakes race to sign them up for what many believe will be a record payout. By comparison, San Diego Gas & Electric paid more than $2 billion for 2007 wildfires that destroyed more than 1,200 homes and killed two people. And PG&E faces more than $1 billion in claims after Cal Fire investigators found it responsible for the 2015 Butte fire, which destroyed 549 homes and also killed two people.
Damages could surpass claims
Gerald Singleton, a San Diego attorney who represents about 500 Napa and Sonoma county wildfire clients in two separate lawsuits, said damages in the Northern California fires could far exceed insurance claims, topping out at $20 billion.
“These fires will absolutely dwarf anything else,” Singleton said. “It will be the largest fire case that’s ever happened. Hopefully, there’ll never be anything bigger.”
He and other lawyers will help people recoup uninsured losses but also go after noneconomic damage, such as emotional distress from fleeing flames and the trauma of being displaced.
Individual settlements for those burned or killed could go into the millions, said another Southern California wildfire attorney, Jim Frantz, who is on a steering committee for lawsuits following the 2015 Porter Ranch natural gas leak outside Los Angeles. He compared North Bay fire lawsuits to litigation following the 2010 BP oil spill, which settled for $20.8 billion.
“It’s the largest man-made disaster in the United States,” Frantz said. “Porter Ranch was terrible. The BP oil spill was bad. This is worse. It’s taken people out of their homes. And the damages will be record-setting.”
The lawyers themselves will take between 33 and 40 percent of any money won in court, plus additional funds to cover their legal and investigative costs. Some charge more if a case goes to trial, billing up to $750 an hour for their time.
Fire victims now are facing an array of decisions as attorneys vie for their business. The State Bar of California warned the public to watch out for fraud, including people posing as lawyers and attorneys who make false promises or inappropriate solicitations.