Finally, great seafood in Napa: Cindy Pawlcyn's latest venture, Go Fish, includes sushi master Ken Tominaga

Reviewed on Sunday, October 29, 2006

The Napa Valley has many restaurants that serve thick, juicy steaks that stand up to its world-famous cabernet sauvignons. But until now, it didn't have a dedicated fish restaurant to pair with its equally delicious chardonnays and sauvignon blancs.

Go Fish in St. Helena, the latest venture from restaurateur Cindy Pawlcyn, fills that niche to overflowing. She's teamed up with sushi master Ken Tominaga of Hana Japanese Restaurant in Rohnert Park to create a truly global fish house. Seafood is flown in daily from Asia, Hawaii, Europe and the coasts of North America.

The building was formerly Pinot Blanc, a restaurant with Los Angeles-style class that never really succeeded. The Napa Valley's elegance has always been a thin veneer over a jeans-and-T-shirt world of grape farmers and hose pullers.

That insight is shown perfectly in the simple decor of Go Fish that, when you look closely, has some very elegant touches. The long sushi and sashimi bar that zigzags back into the restaurant is topped with Carrera marble, hewn from the Tuscan mountain that yielded stone for Michaelangelo's sculptures. The metallic blue, black and coppery fish that separates the sushi bar from the dining area is a brilliant piece of work. The floor is set with thousands of minitiles. Pillows and plush banquettes are upholstered in rich Donghia fabrics.

The architect was the renowned Howard Backen, whose office is just a few hundred yards away. Backen's overall design for Go Fish is luxurious simplicity with Japanese overtones.

Pawlcyn's hand is evident in the relaxed, friendly feel of the place, a little more upscale than her other Napa Valley restaurants (Mustards and Cindy's Backstreet Kitchen), but not at all snooty. The David Bowie and B.B. King on the sound system help keep the place grounded. Tables are set simply, with white linens, a salt cellar and a pepper grinder. The lighting is soft.

Service is first-rate. Whatever utensils are left on the plate will be removed with the finished dishes and replaced immediately. The staff is coolly efficient and warmly engaging. I found myself thinking, ''I like being here.''

That feeling only increased as I perused the wine list. Prices are reasonable -- not always true at Napa Valley restaurants -- and the range of wines, especially the whites, is stunning. Yes, you'll find chardonnay and sauvignon blanc, but also a Greco di Tufo from the Naples area for $25, a vermentino from Sardinia for $24, a torrontes from Argentina for $25, a gruner veltliner from Austria for $44, plus riesling, pinot blanc, pinot gris, gewurztraminer, chenin blanc, semillon, albarino, grenache blanc, viognier, roussanne and more from regions around the world. The whites are served cool but not so iced that you can't taste them.

And if you're having sushi or sashimi and want to go Japanese, you can choose among 16 sakes in a wide range of styles.

Let's say that someone in your party doesn't like seafood -- raw or cooked -- or has an allergy. There is vegetarian ravioli, grilled chicken, and a 24-ounce T-bone ($45) on the menu to accommodate them. But it's the seafood you go for.

At $2.50 each, the oysters on the half shell aren't cheap, but the

Atlantic Oysters ($7.50 for three ****) were outstanding. These aren't from East Coast waters, but are the superior East Coast native species of oyster (Crassostrea virginica) grown in the clean, cold waters of the West Coast. The result is the best of both worlds -- delicate, briny, delicious morsels served ice cold with three dipping sauces (real oyster lovers avoid such sauces in favor a squirt of lemon juice).

The sushi bar serves 31 kinds of nigiri sushi and 20 makimono (rolls) sushi. You get two pieces when you order nigiri. The Unagi Sushi ($7 **** ), freshwater eel, reminded me why Tominaga's restaurant in Rohnert Park is so highly regarded. Each of the two pieces was made from white rice, with the grains cooked so perfectly they barely held together, rather than welding themselves into a sticky clump they way they do at lesser places. Two generous pieces of grilled eel were laid on top of each sushi, and a black band of seaweed was wrapped around the middle of each piece.

Four slices of velvety Hobbs' Smoked Salmon ($11 ****) are served under a salad of red and golden roasted baby beet rounds mixed with baby arugula, all ingredients cold and drizzled with creme fraiche. It's no chore eating through the salad to get to the perfect smoked salmon.

Wild-caught prawns from the Gulf of Mexico set the standard for quality, especially if, like these at Go Fish, they are flown in fresh and have never been frozen. Six Salt-Crusted Gulf Prawns ($10 ***1/2 ) arrive shells on, lightly floured and rolled in salt crystals, then flash deep-fried. The prawns are meant to be eaten crunchy shells and all, dipped in the accompanying sweet and sour sauce.

All Chinese-style food should be as delightfully light and refreshing as the Lobster, Shrimp, and Shiitake Wontons ($12 ***1/2 ) that swim in a spicy ginger-scallion broth.

And there's nothing poor about the Oyster Po Boy Sandwich ($11 ***) that is served on a house-made buttermilk roll. Battered and fried oysters, lettuce and chunks of tomato fill the roll to a size requiring a larger mouth than mine to get a complete bite. Just the aroma of it gets the salivary glands working. It's served with potato chips and pickled vegetables.

The only real ding of the evening occurred, unfortunately, with the main entree. Fish entrees are set up in two categories: Fish Our Way and Fish Your Way. The former category is cooked and sauced as the kitchen determines, but in Fish Your Way, you choose whether the fish is wood grilled, sauteed or steamed, and you choose from among six sauces to accompany it. I chose Rhode Island Striped Bass ($28 **) to be wood grilled and given a tomatillo and avocado salsa. The salsa was fine, but the fish, although bone white and moist inside, was black where the hot grill had touched it -- burnt rather than seared brown -- which suffused the flesh with an unpleasant, acrid taste.

The dessert menu includes some enticing items, like the roasted banana-rum ice cream sandwich with house-made banana bread and almond toffee, but I went with the Lemon Tart with Fresh Huckleberries ($8 ***) and was happy for it. The tart's crust was flaky and light, the lemon curd sweetly sour, and the huckleberries had been lightly cooked but still popped when I bit them to release that intense huckleberry flavor.

To sum up: The team of Cindy Pawlcyn and Ken Tominaga lays a seafood feast of the highest quality before us lucky locals and traveling tourists.

Restaurant: Go Fish, 641 Main St., St. Helena.

When: Open seven days a week with the same menu all day, from 11:30 a.m. to 9:30 p.m. Sunday through Thursday, and to 10:30 p.m. Friday and Saturday. The sushi bar is open from 11:30 a.m. to 10:30 p.m. daily.

Reservations: Absolutely at peak hours. Call 963-0700.

Price range: Moderate to very expensive, with entrees from $14 to $28.

Wine list: ****

Service: ***1/2

Ambience: ***1/2

Food: ***1/2

Overall: ***1/2

UPDATED: Please read and follow our commenting policy:
  • This is a family newspaper, please use a kind and respectful tone.
  • No profanity, hate speech or personal attacks. No off-topic remarks.
  • No disinformation about current events.
  • We will remove any comments — or commenters — that do not follow this commenting policy.