One of the world’s largest land conservation groups has stepped into the battle between environmentalists and local ranchers over the future of private cattle and dairy ranching in Point Reyes National Seashore.
A closely guarded secret until now, The Nature Conservancy is mediating between ranchers who have been part of the North Bay economy for generations and environmental groups who say the cattle and dairy operations harm wildlife, contaminate waterways with fecal bacteria and otherwise degrade the environment.
The Nature Conservancy’s involvement is a new twist in contentious negotiations that could reshape life on the scenic 71,000-acre peninsula, where, in an unusual arrangement, tule elk graze on some of the same grass as dairy cows and cattle on federally protected land.
Those concerned include Albert Straus, founder and executive chair of Straus Family Creamery, which buys about 15% of its milk from the Mendoza and Nunes dairies in Point Reyes. Straus himself is not directly involved in settlement talks, which are being conducted under confidentiality agreements, but has an interest in the outcome.
“We just found out a few weeks ago that The Nature Conservancy is working with the park to remove all the ranches and dairies out of Point Reyes, to buy out their leases,” Straus said.
Citing sources involved, Straus said The Nature Conservancy required all Point Reyes ranchers to sign nondisclosure agreements, in addition to the standard mediation gag order, “which is totally contrary to the public interest,” he said.
But others say The Nature Conservancy aims to bring warring factions together to find a path out of litigation that reconciles ranchers’ obligation to operate without impairing park resources if they are to stay.
“The Nature Conservancy was invited by all of the litigating parties to join the mediation, with the intention of helping to secure a long-term resolution,” said court-appointed case mediator Bradley O’Brien in a statement to The Press Democrat Monday. “TNC is voluntarily participating in the mediation and is not a party to the litigation.”
The seashore’s dairy and cattle ranches, many of them third and fourth-generation family farms that predate the creation of the park, have been around for more than a century.
They have been mired for the past two years in a federal lawsuit brought against the seashore by the Marin-based Resource Renewal Institute, and two national groups, Center for Biological Diversity and Western Watersheds Project. More than a dozen dairy and cattle ranchers have intervened on the park’s side.
Stuck in mediation and settlement negotiations, the case is the latest of several protracted legal and political tests of an idea at the heart of seashore’s origin more than 60 years ago: that a vast and mostly wild landscape transferred into public ownership could still accommodate its ranching tradition.
Representatives for the environmental groups spearheading the lawsuit were not available or declined to comment because of confidentiality around the mediation process.
Most Point Reyes ranchers would not comment for the same reason or did not return calls seeking comment. Rancher Bob McClure declined to comment and jokingly quoted his Tomales High School Spanish teacher Annie Rook, saying, “En boca cerrada no entran moscas” — “In a closed mouth, no flies will enter.”
Berkeley environmental writer and activist Kenneth Brower, son of the Sierra Club’s first executive director, David Brower, said he found word of the conservancy’s involvement “encouraging.”
“It’s an opportunity for us to restore this national park to what it should be, which it should not be a commercial cattle operation,” Brower said, noting his father was “the tall guy on the far right of the photo” of President John F. Kennedy when he signed the seashore’s enabling legislation in 1962.
Others close to negotiations warn that it’s too early to rush to judgment.
“I would caution people not to speculate about ongoing confidential settlement negotiations,” said North Coast Rep. Jared Huffman, D-San Rafael, who has been an outspoken supporter of the national seashore’s ranching traditions. “It’s always tempting for folks to engage in the intrigue and speculation from outside of the room. But there’s a reason why there’s confidentiality around settlement negotiations, and unless and until we have a deal, everything else is conjecture.”
UPDATED: Please read and follow our commenting policy: